MovieChat Forums > Oliver! (1968) Discussion > Pick A Pocket or Two segment

Pick A Pocket or Two segment


I realize Oliver is a bit of a naive kid, but could anyone really be stupid enough to not see what's going on with Fagin and the other kids? I know Fagin tells Oliver it's just a game, but he claims "our line of business pays a little better." At that age, I would've probably put two and two together and figured out what was going on.

reply

He may have known what they were doing, but not that it was a bad thing to do, and illegal.

reply

But all the pickpockets keep pretending that they made the stuff like the wallet after the song.

reply

The thing you're talking about was a problem in the original book. Oliver is made out to be such a figure of innocence and purity that he doesn't know what's going on and so comes across as a complete annoying dope. Oliver's personality is why I think Dickens focused more on the other unsavory characters as the book progressed and seemed to have more fun acting out their roles in public. (He used to do public readings of his book, and it was said he didn't really become animated until he played the evil characters.) Fagin, Sykes, Monks, etc. are more nuanced and in some ways more human. Oliver is pretty much a plot device, where his only purpose is to be the naive, doe-eyed kid who never realizes what's happening more than half the time.

reply

He'd been locked away in the workhouse and taught basically nothing.

reply