Unrealistic Boss


One thing that I couldn't get over was the unrealistic boss who steals sister George's girl. That woman is the epitome of a creepy catty straight woman. No way she's gay.

reply

The Coral Browne character was always ambiguous.

She contradicts her character if you look closely at her performance in the film.

Firstly, when she first meets the Childie character played by Susannah York, she checks her out. Note eye movement.

Yet when they are in the Gateways Club, she acts all shocked at seeing women dancing together and kissing.

But it is always taken that she's a lesbian and Coral Browne played her as so.

reply

I really enjoyed the ambiguity of the Browne character. In the club, her initial reaction could be interpreted as disdain for the swinging gay crowd, as one who is above that kind of scene. But watch carefully when she is alone at the bar: - in a beautiful moment of close-up acting, while her lips remain downturned, there is a hint of a cat-with-the cream smile (I wish I knew how she did it). While I haven't worked in TV, judging by the theatre people I've known, the Browne part is not just believable -- she's even nicely underplayed.

reply

It's an interesting role. In a way, she's lying to herself even more than George or Childie. She wants to see what she wants to see and she doesn't want to think that she may be going through a similar messy breakup scene down the road--only with her in George's place.

Not that George was perfect, but Childie was a piece of work. It sure looked like she was using Mercy just to get away from George. And Mercy was so desperate for love, she was willing to go along with it, thinking that it would become true love or lust or some such thing. I almost felt sorry for her...but not quite.

reply

Yet when they are in the Gateways Club, she acts all shocked at seeing women dancing together and kissing.

I didn't get that. She seemed rather enthralled.



"YOU REMIND ME TODAY OF A SMALL MEXICAN CHIHUAHUA"
http://tinyurl.com/yqwurw

reply

Epitome? I think the word you are looking for is stereotype.

I don't know about "unrealistic" - how many female, closeted network execs have you known to make a comparison?

So, if someone is gay they can't be creepy or catty? (not that I even agree with those descriptives)

reply

I don't agree that she herself was creepy. But the "love scene" was kinda shot to make her look creepy. Thats why we need a remake. Because Mercy looked like the witch on Sleeping Beauty. She looked menacing, when she clearly enjoyed it. But it was shot in the 1960s so they couldnt make it more warm. Rewatch it and look at the shadows they placed on her face and how pale she looked, it was shot to look kinda creepy.

But if we had a remake and cast Demi Moore as Mercy, it would be totally beliveable. Bosses do steal spouses.

reply

Did you mean to reply to the original poster? Because my comment was aimed at the ridiculous assertion of the original poster which was "That woman is the epitome of a creepy catty straight woman. No way she's gay." Yawn...

Ayway, why would they make it warm? As Aldrich described her in that scene (aesthetically) she supposed to a "Dracula-style heavy." A warm and fuzzy scene wouldn't fit the picture no matter when it was shot.

And it absolutely does not need to be remade.

reply

I do not agree with the re-making of this film, i hope it will never be considered for a remake. It is fine as it is. And besides show me any re-made films that are actually good.

Anyhoo regarding Mercy, i have read other peoples posts and i have to say i never found Mercy creepy at all. BUT i do think the sex scene at the end was made to look sort of sinister. The music was a little bit eery.

I thought the part where they were kissing and Childie pushes mercys head towards her breast for me hinted that Mercy had no experience of any sort of lesbian sexual encounter.

Oh! If they are foolish enough to make a re-make, then i think carolyn Seymour would make a brilliant Mercy Croft.

reply

Remake= Necessary to explore the character further in ways no one wanted to touch back in the 60's.

reply

Instead of a remake, I'd rather see a contemporary film that explores these issues seriously and not just for the sake of the T&A-obsessed demographic. The closest thing I can think of recently is "Notes on a Scandal."

reply

Mercy seems anxious to state he was once married to a man when we first meet her. My take on her was she was in denial of herself, deeply clossetted but confused by her attraction to Childie. It would explain her contradictory facial reactions in the club. It is possible that her love scene with Childie was her first time.

reply

Good point. She does go out of her way to distance herself from the lesbians, but at the same time she's very curious about this exotic world she's probably only dreamed of. It's quite possible Childie was her first experience with a woman because it seemed very awkward for her.

reply

Her disgusted facial expressions in the club could be slight envy that these women are so open and free about their sexuality whereas she has to cover it up. She mentions her marriage in her first scene but we know how many marriages in show biz are "of convenience" for a lavender cover-up.

reply

Regardless of whether she was lesbian, she would be shocked by what she saw openly expressed in the club because seeing other women so comfortable with themselves reminded her of how uncomfortable she was. What is liberating to some is threatening to others. And this was the era when women (and men) were expected to get married. Not much was said about the love that dare not speak its name.

reply

Seconded. Also because this is a great story, and deserves a second telling.

reply

I love when George says to Mrs Croft, "Are you thoroughly incapable of saying what you mean?" That's the essence of Mrs Croft. Everything she says and does is a mask.

reply

I am very much against remakes, but the one film that always springs to mind, when I feel there is justification for a remake is 'The Killing of Sister George'.

This 1968 version was very explicit for the time, but it still skirts around subjects due to the era it was filmed in. If the picture was remade, I really do think they would be able to tell more. To be honest, it would even make a good TV series. This would enable them to build everything up for further.

reply