if YOU had final cut...


I just watched this movie for the second time yesterday and although I enjoyed it more than I did the first time, I felt that the movie would have been better if it was more condensed. As it is, the movie feels almost like two movies spliced together. On the one hand you have Potts trying to sell his Toot Sweets candy invention. And on the other hand you have Vulgaria, the Child Catcher, etc.
I'm curious to hear what others have to say about this. If you had final cut on the movie, would you make it shorter? And if so, what would you cut out?

reply

I personally think the movie doesn't really start until the vulgaria scenes. They are not part of the book, however they add to the suspense and action of the movie.

I find right from the beginning scenes could have been shorter or cut. The original race is much to long, and it takes forever until the first good musical scene of the ole bamboo where he gets the money to work on the car (remembering that the car is the star of the film. Lonely man seems wasted on children and is stretched to great lengths.

Also as a teen then adult seeing the movie, i do have to say the baroness must stay as she really got my teen thoughts going :)

reply

I would cut out absolutely everything and start over from the beginning. Read Ian Fleming's original novel to see how this film should have looked, including Edward Gorey's illustrations.

reply

Personally I could care less about it being shorter or true to Fleming's book, I enjoy it exactly as is, and I get great joy watching Dick Van Dyke in his dance scenes. A real gem of a movie IMHO...

reply

I enjoy it as it is despite the feeling sometimes it is big for the sake of it - it was the era of the big roadshow musical!. Some of the songs - Posh, Lovely Lonely Man, Roses of Success - could easily be cut without damaging the story, though I guess you could argue LLM is evidence of Truly's growing feelings for Potts.

reply

It would work better as a two-parter, certainly.

reply

I'm fascinated by the idea of a man who seems to be an expatriate north american who nonetheless has a thoroughly english father, a man who is presently a widower (or a divorcee) living in Nowheresville, southern England, with two children who seem to take more after their mother than their father. I'd like to know more about what happened that sundered this family and whether this tragedy was what pushed Potts into his present avocation as an inventor. Why does this man, who is clearly an urbanite, prefer to live in a rural countryside, despite clearly having an obsession with technology? In a world that already has radio he is interested in developing television; in a world that already has powered flight, he wants to develop rocket propulsion.

I would have included scenes and dialogue at least partly explaining some of this, instead of simply presenting Potts as a hopelessly impractical man living in a relentlessly practical world.

reply

The whole sequence with the two spies and the sequence with grandpa and the old inventors were just filler and could be cut easily. Plus judicious editing in the first hour.

reply

It is a bit sprawling for the kind of film that it is. I might have cut down some of the spies antics, and maybe slim down Pott's scene where he's showing Truly his inventions and what not.

Otherwise I think the film is actually fine as is.

reply

As an adult, I would agree with cutting the spy's, however I loved that part as a kid. mushy scenes like "lonely man" could have been cut, kid's never care about love stories. The very beginning with the car race could have been much shorter, and the movie takes forever to develop. Doesn't really get going to the ole bamboo scene

reply

i would cut out the silly ending where it turns out none of it really happened. And might change the plot generally to make it more like the original story.

reply