Remake


I like this movie just the way it is. However, I would not mind a remake. There is a very good message in this film that I believe would resonate well today. A remake would allow the film to be shown in theatres and make it more appealing to younger audiences.

I've been thinking about who I would like for the lead roles and it is tough to come up with names. So far, I have the following:

1) Jim Carey - Phil Newman
2) George Clooney - Justin Young
3) Kevin Spacey - Walter Braddock
4) Madonna - Mrs. Young

I don't know if Marisa Tomei could play Mrs. Campbell, but I can't think of an alternative. Or she can probably play Mrs. Braddock.

Comments?

reply

Actually there is a similar movie with a similar story line being filmed now.
Based on the ABBA stage play, "Mamma Mia."

The play was terrific and it wasn't until half way through that I realized how close to Buona Sera it really was.

reply

Funny, I was thinking about a remake as I watched it today - but my cast would be quite different:

1. Steve Martin - Walter Braddock
2. Robin Williams - Justin Young
3. Billy Crystal - Phil Newman
4. Monica Bellucci as Mrs. Campbell
5. Beverly D'Angelo as Mrs. Braddock
6. Jennifer Coolidge as Mrs. Newman
7. Catherine O'Hara as Mrs. Braddock

reply

Great casting ideas from everyone. However, my one thought is this - how would the plot be changed? I mean, it couldn't be about a WWII reunion as a backdrop? Any ideas?

reply

You could change Italy to Viet Nam, but then the 'current timeline' would need to be the late 80s, early 90s.

Alternatively, Desert Storm could be the backdrop. but Mrs. Campbell would have to be other than Muslim... maybe it could have been in one of the supporting countries, such as Israel or somewhere in the Med. It would have been too dangerous for a Muslim woman to have gotten pregnant by or married an American at the time. The problem being that in a more modern war, troops wouldn't have been barracked with civilian families.

reply

This film had already been re-made. First as the international stage musical hit, MAMMA MIA! and now coming in June 2008 the film version of MAMMA MIA! A lot of people have no idea that MAMMA MIA is based on this 1968 film with some slight alterations here and there but otherwise it's the same story.

reply

Are we the only ones who noticed this? How come all the publicity attached to the new "Mamma Mia" hasn't brought this to the attention of the public? People are being paid for original story and adaptation. How come there's no outcry?
Are the movie reviewers and PR people all too young to know?

reply

Oh please no one cares hense there is no OUTCRY.

reply

Well, I care. The previous poster, who said that people were being paid for an original screenplay and story, is quite correct. If for no other reason than common decency, Norman Panama and Denis Norden should at least have been given an acknowledgment as the inspiration for Mama Mia. That wouldn't have hurt anyone.

reply

Common decency. How right you are. Well said.

reply

Supposedly, this film was a flop - at least at the box office? - so perhaps that's why no one is trying to go out of their way to acknowledge the truth (which is, BTW, mentioned in the FAQ of "Mamma Mia").


Those who study history are doomed to watch others repeat it.

reply

Which was the flop, "Buona Sera Mrs. Campbell" or "Mamma Mia?" The big problem with the latter is that today, at the end of the day, there are paternity tests that can establish fatherhood with 96% accuracy. Besides, what's the big deal? There's no law that says you can't use the same basic plot as long as the rest of it is original. It's done all the time. Aren't there only about 40 basic plots anyway?

I didn't like Lolabrigida''s character. She was the typical stereotype WWII Italian "Don't judge me; I whored to survive" tramp I've seen a dozen times before. Do they ever do that to French, Dutch, Belgian, or even German women in movies? They all did it in real life.

Actually, I was also surprised that none of the three fathers were Italian-American ex-GIs. They tended to mess around most with Italian women back then because many of them were the sons of immigrants and could speak Italian. As a veteran, I know war forces decent women to desperation, but "Mrs. Campbell" was well past that stage when the reunion occurred.

As for "Mamma Mia," all I can say is - different generation.

reply

I just watched "Buona sera"--what a delight, totally underrated.

There is no doubt that "Mamma Mia!" took its plot from this movie. Still, I wouldn't criticize it too much for that. The real genius of that play/movie was fitting the Abba songbook into the storyline to make a musical of it. That, and Meryl Streep (of course) in the Gina Lollobrigida role.

Have to agree that Monica Bellucci would be a good choice--it would have to be something later than WWII, though, now--maybe the US forces which have been on bases in italy ever since.

reply

I would like to see Maria Grazia Cucinotta as Mrs. Campbell if there's a remake.
She has a great flair for comedy. See "Pick Up the Pieces" or "Just One Night".

reply

flavia18 says > Supposedly, this film was a flop - at least at the box office? - so perhaps that's why no one is trying to go out of their way to acknowledge the truth (which is, BTW, mentioned in the FAQ of "Mamma Mia").
I’m glad to hear this movie flopped but I’m surprised. It’s a typical 1960's movie. It seems the only purpose in making it was to exploit the changes in the attitudes towards sex in society. It had become acceptable to talk about sex so it was a recurring theme in a lot of the movies made during that time.

I didn't like the absolute disregard with which the issue is addressed in this movie. We're told 'Mrs. Campbell' was a sixteen year old girl when she slept with three different men within a short span of time and became pregnant. They did allude to it being during the war but that's about it.

It's clear the war changed people's views on a lot of things, including sex, but I think that should have been dealt with a lot better in the movie. In Italy, and in other war-torn countries, people had to do all kinds of things they wouldn't ordinarily have done just to survive. Most likely a sixteen year old girl would have 'sold' herself in exchange for provisions and money so she and her family could eat another day. A lot of girls and women were also raped during the war.

That's not exactly the way things are portrayed in the movie. It was supposedly all in good fun. It's true sometimes the girls fell in love with servicemen and knowing they might never see each other again they slept together but that did not seem to be the case with young Carla. She made it seem like the guys were around so she had sex with them.

I know the movie is a comedy but I think it made too much light of some rather serious topics. I don't think it's ever a good thing for a woman to have so many lovers, especially within the same timeframe, that they can't figure out who fathered their child. Today there are DNA tests but it's still a sad state of affairs when one needs a test to know whose child they've had.

Remember girls, if you can get pregnant, you can also get other much less desirable things. A moment of fun can cost you your health and your life. Is it worth the risk to sleep with someone you don’t even know?


Woman, man! That's the way it should be Tarzan. [Tarzan and his mate]

reply

I saw this movie many years ago and watched it several times over the years. It really holds up just as it is. I think the story line from Mamma Mia sounds very similiar to this oldie but goodie.

Maria114

reply

I think the remake has already been made and just released. Try Mamma Mia!

reply

This film was not a flop. It was a success, and even if it hadn't been, it should be recognized as the source material for much of Mama Mia.

reply

The best role in this movie was done by Phillip Leroy...a handsome Italian/French actor. He had one big scene towards the end. Both B S M C and Mama Mia were not considered hits in the monetary world...especially Mama Mia. Meryl Streep does make an occasion bomb you know.

reply

[deleted]