MovieChat Forums > 2001: A Space Odyssey (1968) Discussion > The Dawn of Man: Interesting detail

The Dawn of Man: Interesting detail


Just watched this again recently, I noticed something in the first 'act':

At the beginning we see a dry arid planet with a few animals but very little vegetation. After the ape has the epiphany about using animal bones as weapons to kill other animals, we then see him eating some sort of meaty substance which we can assume is from one of the dead animals (is it a tapir?). If you look at that scene you'll see that straight away there is more grass or vegetation in this shot.

To me, that suggests that the other animals were over-grazing the land and clearing it of any kind of plant life before it could grow. By killing those animals, more plants were allowed to grow, meaning the land could become more lush and fertile.

Anyone else notice this?

reply

I've been watching this movie since I first saw it in 1968 on its initial release, and I never noticed that. But it's not at all out of place, conceptually. I'm not sure if we can assume enough time has passed between Moonwatcher's epiphany and the scenes of meat-eating to assume plant life has had a chance to burgeon. But a film does have the ability to telescope time, so you could easily be correct, and this is the very impression Kubrick meant to convey.

Nice theory, whatever the case!




The Dumpster gives a whole new meaning to "red" states.

reply

[deleted]

I only see one large bone lying in front of the ape. Did he throw all of the other bones into the sky and they mysteriously did not come BACK DOWN!?

"gonna throw, my raincoat in the river...gonna toss, my umbrella in the sea"...Sammy Turner.

reply

He means a different area - not near where the apes were living/foraging. The implication is MoonWatcher kills and takes his meat somewhere else to eat. In secret.

Interesting detail: this evolved into hiding to beat one's meat.



Buy The Ticket, Take The Ride

reply

[deleted]