MovieChat Forums > Robbery (1967) Discussion > saw it on tv yesterday,not as good as I ...

saw it on tv yesterday,not as good as I remembered


SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS SPOILERS

This was shown on ITV in the UK on Thursday 16th April 2009.
My diary says under 16TH APRIL,
"SENTENCES TOTALLING 307 YEARS PASSED ON 12 MEN WHO STOLE £2.6M IN THE GREAT TRAIN ROBBERY 1964".

So someone at ITV is on the ball!!!!.



Watching the film for the first time in many years (I admit I missed the first 20 minutes)I was struck that the film could have been better structured.

You get the build up,the actual robbery and the police hunt but there is too much action near the start of the film and not enough near the end.

Given that the film is not meant to be an exact retelling of the GREAT TRAIN ROBBERY STORY then why not spice it up with more action in the second part of the film?

There was a huge police operation to try and catch the robbers but this is only hinted at in the film.


One thing that makes me think from watching this is the question,did the railway workers and postal workers who helped the robbers get caught and punished or not?

I am a railwayman and there is a sort of family spirit in the industry,it would have been stronger back in the 1960s so anybody helping to kill a driver would not be popular.

reply

I wasnt aware of the dates of the showing and the sentences but im not surprised about that. I worked with a girl who used to work for a tv production company, researching and putting together production ideas that are then sent to broadcaster for commissioning.

Many of the programming creatives are instigated by doing desk research for events and where their anniversaries fall into the year. I wouldnt be surprised if a documentary or such like was rejected but the date was pencilled in to show the film.

Anyways, perhaps you are right about your criticisms of the film, but i hadnt seen this one before, so for me it was a real gem discovery. Highly stylised to the point it could perhaps keep company alongside more celebrated films like Get Carter. Very inventive too, i wouldnt be surprised if the mini offload from the removals lorry with the prison break scene, influenced the italian job. I dont know this to be the case but it stands to reason as likely.

Reading around i found out that the car chase scene led to the director being brought into to do Bullitt. Yeah all in all the film is a quality flik, and a real gem if like me you had never happened on it before.

reply

You really can't take a 40+yo. film an expectt that it will be up to 21 practices even in terms of story development, never mind filming.
"Robbery,Bullitt" were considered huge advances in their time. If they seem a bit off that standard now it's probably just a normal course of things.

"Mr. Willoughby, you are not welcome here."

reply

The car chase towards the beginning of the film is quite spectacular.
I don't think you could film it like that on todays London streets.
A great film and I agree it doesn't have the same recognition as other films of its time.
Tremendous cast, some of them were later to become household names, Frank Finlay, Barry Foster, Glynn Edwards and a very young Robert Powell.

reply

Yeah, I liked the film a lot, but in most part the fun stopped after the job was pulled - a film that had been so deliciously intricate and detailed to the smallest minutiae, suddenly decided to take something of a shortcut to the ending. Not sure why. Maybe they thought the running time was getting too excessive to hold attention or whatever... which, of course, was a miscalculation right there as the film was breezing by like, well, a freight train. Engaging stuff from minute one as it was, with all the complicated pre-planning shenanigans dished out at a swift and steady clip, no bullsh-t or waste of time. Up until the post-robbery phase, I thought it ain´t no worse in any way than the best films of its sort, Rififi and all that... well, that saw a tiny bit of revision. But in the end it´s still a near-great caper since there´s nothing overtly ´bad´ about the last act as it were - it just coulda been more. Allaround fine acting, too, and Peter Yates as a crime movie director appears to be unduely overlooked - Bullitt, The Friends Of Eddie Coyle and this one here are all rather outstanding in their genre.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Pretty good - 7.5

"She let me go."
~White Oleander

reply

I liked it

my rating 7/10

reply