MovieChat Forums > Point BlankĀ (1967) Discussion > Remade as Mel Gibson's Payback

Remade as Mel Gibson's Payback


If you have seen Mel Gibson's Payback of 1999, it takes about 5 minutes of viewing this film to realize Payback was nothing but a remake of it. Both movies are based on the same source novel and chocked full of similarities. My question is why Payback isn't listed as "remade as" section of "you might also like" for this movie? It is listed under movie connections, but shouldn't it be both places? How can that be corrected?

reply

It is indeed the same story, but I'm not sure it's technically a remake. Both are based on the novel The Hunter by Richard Stark (pseudonym of Donald Westlake), although neither film uses the character names from the novel. Remake or not, Payback- while a decent crime thriller- doesn't come close to Point Blank IMO.

By the way, The Outfit with Robert Duvall and Parker with Jason Statham are also based on Stark novels featuring the same character.

reply

Just watched Point Blank yesterday and was thinking along the same lines as you. And I agree, Payback should be listed under "you might also like".

reply

[deleted]

Payback is not in the league of this film.

It's that man again!!

reply

Its funny. The films are pretty much the same story, but the difference in 30 plus years of filmmaking is apparent.

Point Blank has very realistic, clear color imagery(thought the editing is New Wave European all over the place)

Payback is filmed in a weird "gray blue" that suggests a black and white film made in color.

Point Blank is fairly low key and realistic about the deaths of the various villains.

Payback goes for modern-day "tough humor" (as in Gibson saying he'll shoot a guy if the answer is "no" from his boss, and the answer is "no" and he shoots the guy.) (as in Carroll O'Connor's scene with two guys with suitcases turning into James Coburn's scene with two guys with suitcases -- in Payback, the suitcases becoming a joke(Gibson makes the two men hold the suitcases so they can't go for their guns; Coburn fires them on the spot.)

In certain ways, Payback is more action-packed and entertaining, and Mel Gibson does a good tough guy ACT.

But in Point Blank, Lee Marvin is, quite simply , a tough guy. He doesn't need all the scenes and schtick that Gibson needs to act tough, he IS tough.

But we'll never have a good comparison of Point Blank to Payback because...Payback was shot with one ending and then reshot with another and we'll never really know which story was better. Point Blank is a movie that was made with the story as intended.

I like both movies. I think Payback is actually more "fun" than Point Blank. But Point Blank is the real deal, a 60's art film noir classic with one of the real tough guys in American film.

reply