Is there a version earlier than this?

I got a copy of this recently for my Father who for the last couple of years has been reminiscing about it. He swears the version he remembers was in B/W and had no sound and was done by either Eric Sykes or Tommy Cooper (I can't remeber who he said). The copy I purchased was this 1967 version, thinking that he might be confusing it and the remake from the 70's but after watching it he's adament about the details above.

Does anyone know if there is an earlier version of this? Maybe he's getting confused with another such skit. If it exists and is available somewhere I'd like to get my hands on a copy if possible.