Anyone else think Smitty is hotter than Rosemary?


Nothing against Michelle Lee, who's a very attractive and charming woman. But that Smitty...must be the glasses. Her bump and grind in "A Secretary is Not a Toy" knocks me out.

reply

I would still vote for Michelle Lee but then I'd vote for her in every movie she's been in.

reply

I think Maureen Arthur is sexier than any of them! The woman was built like a brick *beep* house!!!! <G>

reply

A bit OT but was very impressed with Ruth Kobart in this, and wish she had made more films....The perfect dish for the right person. I did not recognize her at first in "Sister Act"....

"A child of five would understand this. Send someone to fetch a child of five."

reply

I don't know. Just how I would answer this. I first saw this film. When it first came out at Radio City Music Hall. And I was 12 (going on 13).

When I first saw Hedy (Maureen Arthur)! All I could say was WOW!

I just saw this film again today (I had the day off. And saw it on TCM). When I again saw Maureen Arthur. I have to again say. WOW!

There's just something about her performance. Maybe because she really played against type (normally the "dumb secretaries" are blondes. And not redheads)?

I just really don't know? Maybe it's a "Lucy" thing. And I never "loved" "I Love Lucy". In fact the only episode I ever watch. Is the one with George Reeves. As "Superman".

When I see Maureen Arthur in this film. And then remember her in later years in "Empty Nest" and other TV shows when she got really fat and ugly. I almost cry.

It's just so hard to imagine when she was a "looker".

But this film. Reminds me of just that time! When she was HOT! In a very Anita Morris (God Rest Her Soul) sort of way. Yet dumber!

As for Smitty! I'd ply her with a few drinks. Have my way with her. Then go home to Rosemary.

Of course. Michelle Lee was then. And is now someone I would never kick out of bed!

That's my story. And I'm sticking to it!

reply

I'm seven years too late to the thread, but I wholeheartedly agree. When I first saw the movie as a young teen, I had an instant crush on her.

reply

I've only just watched the movie, and I wholeheartedly agree. She was gorgeous.

reply

Smitty --and those glasses. Yes!

reply

https://app.box.com/s/v20x1det5vaa2nlyjovtjoxnlerrwvr1
She seems to be a very capable young woman.

reply