MovieChat Forums > Accident (1967) Discussion > This Movie Is A Masterpiece

This Movie Is A Masterpiece


I confess I didn't like it when I first saw it. Nothing seemed to be happening. Or rather lots of things seemed to be happening, but none of them connected with each other. But that is part of its brilliance. There are no flashy visuals, no attention-getting camera moves: just a steady, intense pitiless glare at these characters as they move around each other and, in some cases, destroy each other.

For the person who was confused by the brutal game of British Bulldog that Michael York and his friends play: this will not surprise once if you understand the English public school. York's character is a product of public school and so is used to cheerful mindless violence. He lives in a great baronial hall, and all he is interested in is ritualised aggression: it sums up the English upper class rather well.

The dialogue is like most dialogue that people speak: to mask what they are saying, not to explain it. Most movies spell out their characters emotions because they are too damn lazy to dramatise them. In this film it is all there beneath the surface. This movie came from an age when there were things beneath the surface.

Like watching paint dry? Paint on a Monet, maybe.

reply

I think "a very good, emotionally distanced movie" (based on an even more distancing novel, from the same writer who provided the source material for Frankenheimer's very rarely seen "Impossible Object") is closer to the truth. But long gone from tv (it used to run on WABC in NY late at night). To be seen, perhaps, during the twilight hours of midsummer, when moral rottenness and weakness seem to leak out of the very shadows on the grass during the last moments of the most otherwise innocent-seeming family picnic. Beautifully acted, but as angrily cold as anything else Joseph Losey ever directed. Dirk Bogarde has more pained anguish in his footsteps than most actors can summon up during an entire career. Also a very composed, graceful movie, probably without a single wasted scene. Definitely worth seeing more than once, but also not something that could easily be made today. Sadly.

reply

If you still might care this astounding film will be on TCM March 26, 2011.

Let it be unsaid: insignificance is the locus of true increpation.

reply

Yeah, it´s quite tantalizingly elliptical storytelling here, keeping the viewer off balance pretty much throughout. Perhaps not 100% successful due to being almost ´too´ low-key and underdramatized at times, but still a remarkably intelligent film with Losey in firm command of the often exquisite aesthetic, bringing Pinter´s excellent script to a vivid life. Not as great as The Servant, but still an outstanding picture. Would rate it 7,5-8/10.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

Beautiful film I've watched a lot of dirk's films and this must be one of his best top 5 films he made

reply