greatest murder mystery


can anyone think of a better murder mystery than Agatha Christie's And Then There Were None? I'd love to hear of any that you consider better. Not talking about this movie (which was OK except for the music and Fabian) but the original novel

reply

The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

reply



good choice - I remember reading both of them years ago and being wowed by them - hard choice. I don't think Ackroyd was ever made into a film

reply

I give "Witness for the Prosecution" a slight, (very slight) edge
over it. I really enjoy "10 little Indians". Its close

reply

ROGER ACKROYD has been filmed twice, as ALIBI in 1931 (based upon a stage play that had starred Charles Laughton) and in 1999 with David Suchet for "Agatha Christie's Poirot" - I don't think Christie was happy with ALIBI on stage or screen, and she wouldn't have been pleased with the Poirot TV-movie either, as it made some changes.

There's been some reconsideration that ROGER ACKROYD isn't quite the masterpiece it's been taken for granted as, aside from it's famous 'twist' - I seem to find it more disappointing each time I re-read it - my latest re-read ended in failure, in fact, about half-way through - surprisingly, this book just plods along - Christie has written far more engagingly elsewhere (particularly in AND THEN THERE WERE NONE).

"In my case, self-absorption is completely justified."

reply

There's been some reconsideration that ROGER ACKROYD isn't quite the masterpiece it's been taken for granted as, aside from it's famous 'twist' - I seem to find it more disappointing each time I re-read it - my latest re-read ended in failure, in fact, about half-way through - surprisingly, this book just plods along - Christie has written far more engagingly elsewhere (particularly in AND THEN THERE WERE NONE).


But the twist itself was so controversial because it had never been done before, and half the mystery world wanted to string Christie up by her thumbs for it. It was only when Dorothy Sayers, then the queen of thrillers, weighed in on Christie's side that the controversy subsided.

What makes Ackroyd a masterpiece, in my anything-but-humble opinion, is how carefully Christie uses language to keep the murderer's identity secret when it would have been ridiculously easy to let something slip. I can only imagine that she reread the manuscript multiple times to make sure there were no mistakes.

reply

I love Frasier´s parody -- Nightmare Inn -- it's hilarious. BTW, It looks like Fabian was never together with anyone else in the film and you didn´t see his face while lying on the floor. For other teenagers in other countries there probably were other hearthrobs injected into the cast. But the best was Murder By Death by Neil Simon with Lionel Twain and the butler Bensonmum.

reply

Jamesir Bensonmum?

reply