Enjoying the debate about whether anyone "made it"...
At first I thought they did. The Old Man talked about a high failure rate, but that would indicate some success. He didn't have any reason to lie to him at that point, as he was going to be killed in a few minutes.
However, the kicker is that they didn't ask him to sponsor anyone before giving him his new life, only after he failed. If they are really hoping you make it, wouldn't they need you to sponsor someone the first time around?
While totally different in lots of ways, this story did remind me of Stephen King's "Quitters Inc." where they force you to stop smoking, get fit, etc. etc. and then force you to bring in another client.