It's rather comic in 2015


Not because of the technology but the stupid moves of the characters.

reply

I could see it having a cult following, but Unforgiven or High Plains Drift are the definitive Eastwood films.

8.9 is unjustified.

reply

I could see it having a cult following, but Unforgiven or High Plains Drift are the definitive Eastwood films.


Most people would 50% disagree with you.

Unforgiven is a benchmark for Eastwood but the Man with No Name/Dollars trilogy put him on the map. They're actually considered one of the first if not the first official trilogy saga. Most would consider The Good the Bad and the Ugly not only Clint Eastwood/Sergio Leone's greatest film but also one of the greatest films/epics of all time. It's pretty much in every greatest films list from reputable sources. Also been listed more than a few times as the single greatest western of all time and introduced the anti-hero to that genre. In addition to that the composed music by Ennio Morricone has been voted one of the best film scores of all time.

Basically, the film is everything.

reply

I guess after so many decades of movies, it's hard to imagine what it was like when something like this first came out, as the first of it's kind, and how it changed everything. I was born in '80, but I grew up watching westerns, and started out on a lot of the older ones. To me, these "spaghetti westerns" were the most epic and made the biggest impression on me, and even now when I watch them, I just think they're so Bad A-- and cool and fun to watch. Nothing like this had come out before, and even afterwards, I don't think any could hold a candle to this movie. Everything about them, from the way they were shot, the story of the characters, the dirty sweaty landscape that was real and not just Hollywood magic, the close-ups of the eyes and the itching hands by the holsters, and the awesome score that elevated & punched up the entire experience. When one watches these films, you can't help but get sucked in, whole-heartedly and believe it all. You're not stopping to question someone's acting, or a camera shot or something, b/c it's that engrossing.

There are some great westerns, of course High Plains Drifter is great. And some feel like Unforgiven is the unspoken sequel to this movie, which is cool to think about and also a fantastic movie. But this is what started it all, and I just can't think of anything greater.

"Are you going to your grave with unlived lives in your veins?" ~ The Good Girl

reply

This trilogy didn't start the spaghetti western frenzy. On release, the films were panned by many critics and only in time have become classics.

.
Ignore what people say; freely state your opinion and be proud of it :)

reply

And don't know why they would think its an unspoken sequel. In no way shape or form does it give you the impression that character from the leone films murdered women and children.

reply

I have to agree with you. I was also born in 1980 and although I only saw these films recently, my father raised me to watch a lot of classic films like Ben Hur or The Godfather films.

What I also like about these trilogy despite it's highly elevated operatic style and drama is the entertaining fun aspect of it. The characters and their interactions/chemistry is fantastic.

And still, it comes across as realistic to me despite the sweeping score, beautiful shots and closeups, and operatic nature and characters.


Global Warming, it's a personal decision innit? - Nigel Tufnel

reply

I disagree. "Rawhide" put him on the map. It's that simple.

reply

Unforgiven is just boring.

reply

I agree. And The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly is one of the best films of all time. In my opinion, it's the best of the Western film genre, period.

reply

I disagree, I love Unforgiven.



Global Warming, it's a personal decision innit? - Nigel Tufnel

reply

Oh well I guess we'll all just stop watching it then. You're a fu2king ja2ka$$. Shut it.

reply

I'm sure you've enjoyed films with even more stupid characters. Greed is a powerful thing.

Yum yum.

reply

I have 34 years and I rated 1062 movies on imdb and I saw just as many as that but this is one if not the best movie ever made.

Raylan Givens: I'm going to need an ambulance, and a coroner.

reply

Agree, I'm pushing 1300 ratings and only 21 10's have been scored. This was a no hesitation 10 and immediately a personal favorite.

reply

Unforgiven is good but some aspects of the plot and dialogue are laid on with a trowel. The initial few viewings are great but it gets a bit thin. The Good the Bad and the Ugly on the other hand is just a stone cold classic.

reply

It's the opposite for me. Watching Unforgiven as a child, I never really understood the buzz. But watching it now, I get it.




Global Warming, it's a personal decision innit? - Nigel Tufnel

reply

Really? Because in 2016 it's great.

reply

I love the movie, but it is something of a comedy.

I am an *beep* but my friends compensate for that.

reply

Yes, it's entertaining but dated and somewhat hokey. Can't imagine how someone who could seriously insist that it's "great." The soundtrack gets on your nerve and some of the dialogue is really awkward. It's a movie that everyone should watch once but I can't imagine watching it again. (Actually, I just watched it again- the fist time was probably about 1985.)

reply

It's a classic and timeless work of art.

reply

You speak about stupid moves but don't say what moves!
I could say the same thing about Nolan's modern "masterpieces" like Inception, Interstellar, The Dark Knight Rises or many of the modern blockbusters with terrible screenplays like Jurassic World or even the classic movies like Jaws which is pretty naively by modern standards!
Every movie has flaws and no movie is perfect but this movie has such high rating because many people grew up loving it and because it's so unique that we probably will never see anything similar again!

reply

[deleted]