MovieChat Forums > The Blue Max (1966) Discussion > class warfare with the lower class as ba...

class warfare with the lower class as bad


Odd to see a film that sticks up for the upper classes and portrays the main character as a jerk. This is following up that whole WW1 as the death of aristocratic chivarly but I'd have liked to see some other lower class characters shown in a good light. Peppard wasn't really a jerk until after Willi's death, his questioned actions before then make sense as a guy trying to prove himself.


If everyone's thinking the same way, someone isn't thinking. Gen. Patton

reply

Regarding the "upper classes", my impression was quite the opposite.


"I told you it was off." The Jackal

reply

In this film? In spite of the General's need for propaganda over honorable actions, "sharing" his wife and then letting Sachel die at the end, the aristos seem to be the ones talking about honor and following the rules. Willi isn't concerned that some of his kills weren't official. The Captain wants Sachel court martialed for his disobeying orders and getting men killed needlessly. Sachel is the one putting his own ambition above country and duty.


If everyone's thinking the same way, someone isn't thinking. Gen. Patton

reply

Think about this though, the way the film sets things up Stachel had spent two years in the trenches before even transfering to the air service and at the beginning of the film throws a bottle of schnapps to a group of bedraggled soldiers at the side of the road.

He`s treated as much of an outsider by the more aristocratic members of the unit who always seem to accuse him of having the worst possible motives for his actions so in the end is it all that surprising that he acts the part?

He knows that he probably isn`t going to live very long so can he really be blamed for taking what he can get when its freely available.

He may have started out as rather idealistic and patriotic but what he`s seen over the last couple of years has rather brutalised him and he just sees the attitude of some of his squadron mates as rather hypocritical.

To me it looks like in the film Stachel has a rather decent side to is character which gets more driven into the background as the story progresses.
The `Blue Max` becoming a way for him to say "I`m just as good as you are" to the rest of the squadron.

"Any plan that involves losing your hat is a BAD plan.""

reply

The upper classes as represented in particular by the general are ruthless and calculating. Stachel is merely ruthless.

SPOILER










The way he brings the stamp down hard on Stachel's file just as his plane is crashing says it all. His class sent millions to their death in that war in the most casual fashion.

"Chicken soup - with a *beep* straw."

reply

Julie Kirgo states it well on her liner notes for the Twilight Time bluray. Heidemann is the old school gentleman officer, desperately holding onto honor and chivalry; none of the other high-ranking officers do. The general is a cynical manipulator; Willi plays the gentleman but sleeps with his aunt. Stachel tries to match them but isn't sly enough to survive.

reply