Fincham hated Ryan's sentimentality and his willingness to compromise. Fincham is a very old-school soldier who sees any compromise as weakness, regardless of any positive outcomes it may have. He's also extremely tired and bitter and considers Ryan inexperienced and foolhardy.
Conversely, Ryan's problem with Fincham was this very same unwillingness to compromise. He thought that his never-say-die attitude caused problems which could've otherwise been avoided. Ignoring that the ultimate responsibility lay with Battaglia, it was clearly Fincham's refusal to cooperate which was to blame for the squalid living conditions of the camp (note that despite his cruelty and callousness, Battaglia did allow conditions to improve after Ryan compromised with him). Ryan also thinks that Fincham is too eager for revenge a lot of the time, and is disturbed his eagerness to use captured enemies as revenge proxies for the crimes of others (for example, von Klement had nothing to do with the SS' massacre of the wounded prisoners, but Fincham was ready and willing to kill him for it).
Both men are right about the other. Ryan is too sentimental and often compromises too much, and lacks experience while being too recklessly willing to assume leadership, while at the same time Fincham is stubborn and needlessly uncooperative, and too eager for vengeance, up to and including using proxies for it if he can't get ahold of the truly guilty ones.
This makes both men extremely realistic and believable as human beings with all of their very understandable flaws.
By themselves, neither man is fit to lead. But together, they balance each other out and for all their griping, they work together quite well. Each makes up for the other's shortcomings. Fincham brings his experience to the table, helping Ryan learn on the job, whilst Ryan tempers Fincham's more violent tendencies, and channels Fincham's directionless anger, helping him keep his mind focused on the task at hand.
"I mean, really, how many times will you look under Jabba's manboobs?"
reply
share