first time watching this.


I just saw this film today and i can't be more joyed as too how much i loved it, and i can't believe it took me such a long time watch this film, i think sound of music and singing in the rain are by far my fav two musicals. the songs are perfect, and the movie took a dark turn, they could of ended the film at the wedding, but went further, there are some unexplained questions such as. were the nuns and the uncle killed off because they helped the von trap family?

reply

Well, it's important to remember that "Uncle Max" was a character who didn't exist; he was a dramatic invention for "The Sound of Music" (first the stage show, then the film). However, he was based on Father Franz Wasner, the individual most responsible for developing the musical talents of the Trapp Family Singers. But he wasn't popular with the Nazis, so he escaped with the family when they crossed the border (by train) into Italy.

The nuns' sabotage of the Nazis' car was another dramatic invention; it never happened. Enjoyable scene, though.

reply

I envy you.

I wish that I could watch my favorite films again as if for the first time.

The poster above explained the characters in this adaptation, but even if things went as shown, would the Nazis have suspected the nuns of all people or would they perhaps think that one of the Von Trapps managed to disable the cars before escaping over the mountains?



Is very bad to steal Jobu's rum. Is very bad.

reply

...would the Nazis have suspected the nuns of all people or would they perhaps think that one of the Von Trapps managed to disable the cars before escaping over the mountains?



A very valid point. As we know, the Nazis weren't the most progressive of thinkers; if their cars had been vandalized, they'd immediately assume the dirty work had done by one of Baron von Trapp's sons. They'd never entertain the notion that a woman could be capable of dismantling an engine.

And while we're on the subject, this is another example of how effectively Robert Wise cast the film. Having the gifted Portia Nelson play Sister Berthe was a master stroke; she's more than believable as an early nemesis for Maria, but she's equally convincing in the final scenes when she (in partnership with Sister Margaretta) thwarts Maria's tormentors. As a matter of fact, the audience LOVES seeing this no-nonsense woman firmly on Maria's side.

Portia Nelson was invaluable to "The Sound of Music" because she brought a welcome touch of vinegar to early scenes that might have become overly saccharine. In addition, she contrasted beautifully with Anna Lee's warm & sweet Sister Margaretta; the audience had no problem believing the two of them could function effectively as a team, because they looked like they had different (but complimentary) skill sets that could be combined to achieve any goal.

reply

"I wish that I could watch my favorite films again as if for the first time."

Set up a movie night and watch your favorite films with your children. I have loved seeing my kids' reaction to movies like SOM, The Wizard of OZ, Back to the Future.

If you ever see that the Sound of Music is playing in a local cinema go watch it on a big screen.

"The end of the shoelace is called the...IT DOESN'T MATTER!"

reply

I just saw this for the first time as well, on a long Austrian Air plane trip. I can't believe I had never seen this before as I was born in the 60's when it came out.

It was absolutely beautiful and I loved it. A forever classic.

reply

Great movie, my 15 month old son loves the music and falls asleep to it. such a classic.

reply

It's a great movie and you get the impression that you never want it to end.

reply

It's a great film, but a movie musical I like even more that doesn't get much credit or airplay nowadays is Fiddler on the Roof. I also highly recommend that one. West Side Story is another must see if you haven't gotten around to seeing that one either.

reply