MovieChat Forums > The Slender Thread (1965) Discussion > Would you like to have met her at the ho...

Would you like to have met her at the hospital at the end?


I was just wondering... if I had essentially saved this woman's life I would have wanted to see her at the hospital -- not looking for a thanks in any way at all but I noticed that he was drawing a simple portrait of a woman while in the beginning of his conversation with her. Perhaps I wouldn't go right away, but I would go in a day or two...

What about anyone else?

You're laborers, you're supposed to be laboring! That's what you get for not having an education!!

reply

I wondered what would have happened if SHE had asked to meet HIM. And if he STILL didn't want to meet her, after all the intense bonding and apparent understanding in their long conversation, would this have caused her to go off the deep end again?

"Shake me up, Judy!"

reply

Exactly: I mean who wouldn't want to be thanked for saving ones life -- although you do it out of being a good samaritan. It's nice to be acknowledged for your good deeds.

You're laborers, you're supposed to be laboring! That's what you get for not having an education!!

reply

My gut reaction was "what? Why doesn't he want to see her?" But after thinking about it a little bit I kind of understand. It might be confusing at that point to have another man in her life.

reply

Indeed. It was a bit disappointing that he didn't want to see her, but he accomplished his goal and can take comfort in the quiet dignity that he saved a stranger's life. The more I think about the ending, the more I like it because it's hopeful but not too obvious.

reply

I just finished watching this film for the third time and once again considered why Alan did not want to meet her. I think I know the answer but in these politically correct days others may not like (or want to know) my line of reasoning. But you have to remember that the film was made in 1965 and set in contemporary times, which were very different from now.

When Inga called the crisis center she was a woman in a desperate situation wand wanted to hang-on to something - anything. Alan, despite his inexperience or maybe because of it, was able to provide that something in the shape of himself. All the while they were talking, he would have formed a reasonably good mental picture of her (refer to his sketching of her) but the converse is not necessarily true. During the course of their conversation he was just another human being trying to help someone in desperation - the proverbial straw to a drowning person. But once Inga recovered in hospital, her conditioning would return and Inga's reaction to a black man would have been very different. She would have been thankful, of course but there was bound to be a certain awkward reservation which Alan, as an intelligent man, would have quickly detected. That would have been a psychological blow to him and spoiled what was essentially a successful effort. Bearing that in mind, he decided to hold back and not meet her, thus leaving her with the image of whatever she chose to make of him.

reply

Seeing that part was tough for me. He told her he was her friend and that he loved her, but he didn't want to meet her? I would've wanted to meet her, not for a thank you, but to meet this person that I just connected with over the phone and to make sure that she was OK.

reply

Different strokes for different blokes. I agree that many would have wanted to meet in those circumstances, but it's entirely possible he may have wanted to move on and clear his head, in case he got another call.🐭

reply