MovieChat Forums > My Fair Lady (1964) Discussion > Could the bath scene be considered sexua...

Could the bath scene be considered sexual assault?


Eliza told the women "No! Get your hands off me!"

If a woman says no, and you continue to try to take her clothes off, that is sexual assault!

Especially since Eliza was screaming in terror.

She sounded like a rape victim!

reply

You could show the same scene with some horror music in the background, it would have some effect.

Darth Vader is scary and I  The Godfather

reply

One word: It's played for comedy. God, I hate PC people with a passion.







"'Extremely High Voltage.' Well, I don't need safety gloves, because I'm Homer SimpsonZZZzzzSSSsssXXXxxxOWCH--" - Frank Grimes

reply

That you hate other people who are trying to be sensitive says a lot.

reply

Overly hyper sensitive

reply

What a stupid question.

reply

It is pretty disturbing! Since their intent was not sexual (and nakedness does not equal sexuality) I don't think it counts as sexual assault, but it would count as physical assault. Plus, the water must have been hot enough to scald her, and that is abuse. When I draw a bath and the water is steaming, that means it's too hot. (FYI I turned my water heater down to 120 degrees F after that.)

reply

That's the point she was meant to sound unrefined and common. She was throwing a tantrum probably just for attention.

I don't know why you thought it sexual?

reply

I agree with OP. It would certainly be considered assault/abuse now. When the movie was made, there was much less consciousness of treating people with respect, of oppression, of equal rights for women.

reply

No and no.
She sounded like a child who didn't want to bathe.

reply

10 years from now, Freddy bringing flowers to Eliza will be considered sexual assault...

reply

And just knowing he's on the street where she lives would be stalking.

Back in high school, I somehow learned a classmate lived on the same street as myself. I thought that was just enough to propose a date. I never heard from her. Now, there are a lot of reasons why she might have chosen not to respond, but I sometimes wonder if it was because of her Middle East background, and she may not have been allowed to be alone with a guy who isn't her husband or a relative.
My neighbor across the street once gave me a ride home from community college when my car battery died, and I think she caught hell for letting me into a car with her, hahaha. She just had this smile on the whole time we were traveling together, like ten minutes, maybe. Her father would bow to Mecca in her driveway, but I think he had passed on before our little dalliance.

reply

And just knowing he's on the street where she lives would be stalking.


LOL! Ashamed of myself for not having thought of that first.

reply

What in the world did you say that had to be deleted?
But I guess that's an answer we'll never know.

reply

The mods didn't delete it, I did.

Here's what happened: my internet was acting wonky again. I posted the message you responded to and went to get a cup of coffee, but the page froze after hitting the add-reply button. I refreshed the page when I came back to the computer and found to my utter horror (I'm easily terrified) that the post was now double-posted.

So, no clever quip, intelligent debate, or anything even trivial to add to what I had already said. How sad is that?

reply

But very funny. Not sad at all. Thanks for the "'splainin' Lucy". Cheers.

reply

[deleted]

At some point in the film I'm pretty sure Henry Higgins touched her shoulder while he was talking to her. Rape!

reply

"Could the bath scene be considered sexual assault?"

Yes...

By idiots.

..Joe

reply