MovieChat Forums > Mary Poppins (1965) Discussion > Mary was a witch, I think we need to adm...

Mary was a witch, I think we need to admit this.


Mary Poppins was a witch. No other way could it explain the things she was able to do short of being magic. While she was a good witch, she was still a witch. I think to deny this fact any longer is living in denial.

reply

If you've read the books, she was actually a fairy -- in the "Old Ways" mould of English mythology, not the modern American style of Disney's version of Tinkerbell.

There are remnants of that in the Disney film - her ability to work apparent magic, and her tendency to get snippy and terse unexpectedly - but frankly, the Disney version of her character doesn't make a lot of sense by comparison.


You might very well think that. I couldn't possibly comment.

reply

puirt-a-beul said

-------------- Begin message -------------------
If you've read the books, she was actually a fairy -- in the "Old Ways" mould of English mythology, not the modern American style of Disney's version of Tinkerbell.

There are remnants of that in the Disney film - her ability to work apparent magic, and her tendency to get snippy and terse unexpectedly - but frankly, the Disney version of her character doesn't make a lot of sense by comparison.

-------------- End message -----------------------

I thought so too - a good fairy without wings

--
*nya* *purr*

reply

by eastcoastguyz » Sun Nov 27 2011 05:28:21 Flag ▼ | Reply |
IMDb member since May 2003
Mary Poppins was a witch. No other way could it explain the things she was able to do short of being magic. While she was a good witch, she was still a witch. I think to deny this fact any longer is living in denial.

Like I give a damn. Who cares?

reply

Well, we can't admit something that isn't true. For crying out, witches aren't he only magical beings in the fictional world.

reply

Oh, yeah? Where's your proof! :-)

reply


Where`s yours?














Dorothy stop that, Mr. Ha Ha`s lookin at you!!

reply

Are you people off your rockers? Proof? About a fictional world. Either you are all joking or you need to grow up. What else should I have expected going to the Mary Poppins discussion than to find adults who haven't gone past childhood.

reply

She turned me into a newt!

reply

Of course she's not, witches have brooms.

reply

We could build a bridge out of her.

reply

Somebody fetch some scales... and a duck!

reply

of course she was a witch!

are people in denial about this or is it a realization that you've suddenly come to?

reply

Is she a GOOD witch, or a BAD witch?.

reply

I really, truly, feel sorry for you. Having watched the most wonderful, magical of films (at least, I ASSUME you actually watched it) the best thing that you can take away from it is that the Practically Perfect Mary Poppins was a witch. Maybe she needs to pay a visit to your house.

reply

As a child, I was truly mesmerized and enjoyed the "magic" of the movie and haven taken away many other wonderful moments. But as an adult, it puts into question the rationale for her "powers" when you consider the history of other female superheros such as Wonder Woman, Super Girl, etc. However, as a mature heterosexual male I would certainly welcome a special visit from Mary Poppins to my house. ;-)

reply

i reckon shes got some surprises at the bottom of that bag ;)

reply

Well, it IS a children's film and, guess what, children accept such premises without having to analyze it all. Not surprising that you have a different perspective as an adult, but the film was not made for that audience.

reply

And? So what. Harry Potter is a witch too. Its fiction honey. And you do realize there are more magical creatures out there in the land of FICTION than just witches, right? If not, it's time to get educated and start reading.

reply

Mary Poppins is not in touch with the Wicca goddess by any stretch of the imagination. If you want to see what a real witch looks like Google 'Nancy Pelosi, Photo'.

reply

Yeah, she's a real witch. Do you have any accomplishments like these below? No, of course not, because you are a troll:

Nancy Pelosi, the Democratic Leader of the U.S. House of Representatives for the 113th Congress, is focused on strengthening America's middle class and creating jobs, reforming the political system to create clean campaigns and fair elections, enacting comprehensive immigration reform, and ensuring safety in America’s communities, neighborhoods and schools. From 2007 to 2011, Pelosi served as Speaker of the House, the first woman to do so in American history.

For 25 years, Leader Pelosi has represented San Francisco, California's 12th District, in Congress. She first made history when House Democrats elected her the first woman to lead a major political party. She has led House Democrats for a decade and previously served as House Democratic Whip.

Under the leadership of Pelosi, the 111th Congress was heralded as "one of the most productive Congresses in history" by Congressional scholar Norman Ornstein. President Barack Obama called Speaker Pelosi “an extraordinary leader for the American people," and the Christian Science Monitor wrote: “…make no mistake: Nancy Pelosi is the most powerful woman in American politics and the most powerful House Speaker since Sam Rayburn a half century ago.”

Working in partnership with President Obama, Speaker Pelosi led House passage of the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act in early 2009 to create and save millions of American jobs, provide relief for American families, and provide a tax cut to 95 percent of working Americans. With the House Democratic Caucus, Pelosi continues to focus on the need to create jobs in America and prevent them from being shipped overseas.

Speaker Pelosi achieved passage of historic health insurance reform legislation in the House which establishes a Patients’ Bill of Rights and will provide insurance for 30 million more Americans while lowering health care costs over the long term. The new law provides patients with affordable insurance choices, curbs abuses by the insurance industry, strengthens Medicare, and reduces the deficit by more than $100 billion over the next 10 years.

In the 111th Congress, Speaker Pelosi also led the Congress in passing strong Wall Street reforms to rein in big banks and protect consumers as well as the Student Aid and Fiscal Responsibility Act, which expands educational opportunities and reforms the financial aid system to save billions of taxpayers’ dollars. Additional key legislation passed into law included the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act to restore the ability of women and all workers to access our judicial system to fight pay discrimination; legislation to provide health care for 11 million American children; national service legislation; and hate crimes legislation. In late 2010, Pelosi led the Congress in passing child nutrition and food safety legislation as well as repealing the discriminatory “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” policy, which prohibited gays and lesbians from serving openly in the military.

Pelosi has made energy security her flagship issue, enacting comprehensive energy legislation in 2007 that raised vehicle fuel efficiency standards for the first time in 32 years and making an historic commitment to American home grown biofuels. In 2009, under her leadership, the House passed the landmark American Clean Energy and Security Act – a comprehensive bill to create clean energy jobs, combat climate change, and transition America to a clean energy economy. The legislation was blocked by Republicans in the United States Senate, but sent a strong signal to the world about the United States’ commitment to fighting the climate crisis.

A leader on the environment at home and abroad, Pelosi secured passage of the “Pelosi amendment” in 1989, now a global tool to assess the potential environmental impacts of development. In San Francisco, Pelosi was the architect of legislation to create the Presidio Trust and transform the former military post into an urban national park.

In continuing to push for accountability and transparency in government, under Speaker Pelosi, the House passed the toughest ethics reform legislation in the history of the Congress, including the creation of an independent ethics panel, and increased accountability and transparency in House operations, including earmark reforms. As Speaker, Pelosi led the fight to pass the DISCLOSE Act in the House, which fights a corporate takeover of U.S. elections and ensures additional disclosure; she continues to fight for this legislation today.

Additional key accomplishments signed into law under the leadership of Speaker Pelosi include: an increase in the minimum wage for the first time in 10 years; the largest college aid expansion since the GI bill; a new GI education bill for veterans of the Iraq and Afghanistan wars; and increased services for veterans, caregivers, and the Veterans Administration.

Pelosi comes from a strong family tradition of public service. Her late father, Thomas D'Alesandro Jr., served as Mayor of Baltimore for 12 years, after representing the city for five terms in Congress. Her brother, Thomas D'Alesandro III, also served as Mayor of Baltimore. She graduated from Trinity College in Washington, D.C. She and her husband, Paul Pelosi, a native of San Francisco, have five grown children and nine grandchildren.

reply

[deleted]

George Bush is the president,not Barack Obama. Only to MTV era Rock the vote kids LOL.

Permanent avatar:Courtney Thorne-Smith
Twitter account:SJCarras
MAGIC=Sarah Silverman.

reply

George Bush is the president,not Barack Obama. Only to MTV era Rock the vote kids LOL.

Permanent avatar:Courtney Thorne-Smith
Twitter account:SJCarras
MAGIC=Sarah Silverman.

reply

Why must politics be brought into every discussion thread. It is quite childish.

reply

Yes, Leave us with your politalk!

We're discussing real world problems:
We're talkin' Wiches here. Yeah, it starts with the fictional ones like Mary P.,
But soon we're seening real witches amongst us!
Who does this Santy Claus guy think he's fooling? Were on to ya, you fat tub of Warlock!
Be Gone!!!


Wait, maybe he's trying to tell us Nancy Pelosi has fallen -- our dear sweet Nancy, a witch?
Say it isn't so !!!





"I've seen so many Kung-Fu movies, I can probably speak Mandolin!"

reply

So brave.

reply

If she wears ruby slippers and striped socks, she's a BAD witch. Or a good Dorothy. Or whatever.

reply