WTF????


Somebody please explain the meaning of this movie...i have read some stuff on the internet but i think its too simple. Particulary i want to know about the girl in the beach story.
Cheers.

Appy-polly-loggies

reply

It's about an unhappy wife who suffers from an unnamed form of depression and malaise, who tries to find meaning in life. it's a very existential art film. the characters are alienated individuals in contemporary life and placed against towering forms of technology to emphasize their smallness and lostness in the modern world of technological change.

reply

So zachhh basically copied and pasted that, because I just read the same thing on mubi.com, on Red Desert's film description...don't take credit for something you didn't write please, thanks :)

reply

[deleted]

It's not merely depression she's suffering, nor malaise which is a bit of a joke "illness", but she's definitely had at least a concussion from which she hasn't recovered---tho at the end her behavior shows us she's recovering, tho not completely, as she's again rushing off to escape her senses which are accentuating noise into those loud electronic sounds.

The people Antonioni was trying to show were in the shape you describe she was in is the audience.

~ Native Angeleno

reply

"A film you can explain in words is not a successful film" /M. Antonioni.
Meaning: you don't need an exact explanation, particularly not from someone else. You either liked it or not, and if you did, the images and feelings will stay with you, or it will inspire you to think, etc., and that's it, really.

This message has not yet been deleted by an administrator

reply

[deleted]

Antonioniennui cranked up to the max, distilled and placed in an even more ominously oppressive surroundings than previously. Giulietta´s line "There´s something terrible about reality... and I don´t know what it is" sums it - as well as more or less the entire Antonioni´s body of work - up pretty accurately.



"facts are stupid things" - Ronald Reagan

reply

After I watched The Red Desert I felt it was about the carelessness of humans either to each other which is shown through Giuliana's relationship with her husband and to nature due to the factories pollution. In this sense The Red Desert also contains an enviroment message.

"I'd rather be hated for who I am, than loved for who I am not".

reply

Beautiful shots of industrial settings doesn't seem to convey any environmental message to me.



~ Observe, and act with clarity. ~

reply

The shots of the industrail settings are not meant to convey an enviromental message. They represent the bleakness of Giulianas Husband's job. The enviromental message comes across in such scenes as when they visited a polluted pond not far from the industrail plant

"I'd rather be hated for who I am, than loved for who I am not".

reply

There were no environmental messages at any point. Perhaps this is a case of seeing things you wish were there, that really weren't.



~ Observe, and act with clarity. ~

reply

[deleted]

There was a scene where they are surrounded by industrial waste. I don't think that scene was "beautiful" like the visually stimulating shots of peculiar shots of industrial buildings. He did try to show the consequences of massive industrialization in that particular scene, but I don't think that it's an enviromentalist film by any means any more than showing an animal carcass in a movie would be an anti-animal movie. There wasn't an emphasis on enviromentalism when the movie was made, that there was to come some decades later. At that point, mass industry was generally seen in a more positive than negative light.

reply

I watched this movie for the first time myself last night and wondered the same thing.

Then I watched parts of it with the commentary on.

The movie was just a vehicle in which antonioni used to experiment with color film and his heavy use of filters on the lenses.

Although the plot is simple, I don't think the move really "means" anything.

reply

It's about how unbearable life can be. Giuliana says it all by stating this and, near the end, that whatever happens to her only happens to her. This is her life, she has to make the best out of it for herself.
"When you pinch someone, it doesn't hurt for you."
This is her way of saying that she has to deal with the pain she feels, as others might not.
We all have our wounds and some of them don't heal, we simply learn to live with them.

If you really want to find a bigger theme, I'd say it's about human beings being able to adapt to their surroundings. Even Antonioni adapts to the new era by experimenting with colour, even painting fruit grey to give us a very subjective introspection of Giuliana's perspective JUST LIKE Giuliana is painting the walls in her future shop to see how they work together. I don't know if today we can always find ourselves in these themes because we are raised in a different world, filled with different media and colour seldomly being exceptional. I do feel a certain resonance with Antonioni though, especially his colour films. It's as if almost any artist dealing with film or photography from that era felt that colour film was superficial and too close to life in order to create something that resembled it so they made it the way they felt like it was yet as a spectator it feels amazingly grand. As if they finally can grasp how abstract life is, that so many words we speak are just blurts of noise when compared to the actions that emphasize or contradict them. I feel deeply with this, Giuliana is overwhelmed by this new world we're entering, even the yellow smoke screams at her yet at the end it feels different. She has come to the point she can accept it even when she's the only one hearing it. There are so many possibilities (like the women in the RED room in the shack), which one to pick? Which ones are right? Wouldn't you feel overwhelmed if anywhere you looked there is something that tells you what to do, what to think, what to feel? I know it sounds neurotic, it probably is.

One last thing, Antonioni didn't use Red Desert as a title unintentionally. Red is a colour of love (acceptance) but also of blood, wounds, vulnerability.

reply