MovieChat Forums > Bande à part (1964) Discussion > This shows Imdb Top 250 Truly sucks

This shows Imdb Top 250 Truly sucks


This movie is hailed as top 25 movie of all time from various critics and reviewers. It should be around top 100 IMDb at least and here it doesn't even make it Top 250.


''Just because you've got the emotional range of a teaspoon doesn't mean we all have''

reply

[deleted]

Well, it's no Shawshank Redemption. LOL!

reply

why not in imdb top 250???
one word:foreign films
this list of great foreign movies i liked 97% not in imdb top 250
0s:

1-The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari
2-Bronenosets Potyomkin
3-The Passion of Joan of Arc
4-Metropolis
5-Pandora's Box

30s:

1-M
2-La grande illusion
3-The Rules of the Game
4-the blue angle
5-L'atalante
6-All Quiet on the Western Front

40s:

1-The Bycicle Thief
2-Beauty and the Beast
3-Children of Paradise
4-late spring


50s:

1-La strada
2-Umberto D.
3-Du rififi chez les hommes
4-Hiroshima mon amour
5-Ikiru
6-Sansho the Bailiff
7-Pickpocket
8-The 400 Blows
9-Los olvidados
10-Forbidden Games
11-Les diaboliques
12-Tokyo Story
13-Pather Panchali
14-A Man Escaped
15-Ugetsu monogatari
16-The Cranes Are Flying

60s:

1-Viridiana
2-Tystnaden
3-Knife in the Water
4-The Leopard
5-Z
7-Au hasard Balthazar
8-The Battle of Algiers
9-Andrey Rublyov
10-L'avventura
11-Last Year at Marienbad
12-Vivre Sa Vie
13-Le samouraï
14-8½
15-Le trou
16-Onibaba
17-Once Upon a Time in the West
18-Band of Outsiders
19-Sundays and Cybele
20-Woman in the Dunes
21-L'eclisse
22-Contempt
23-Jules et Jim
24-Mouchette

70s:
1-Aguirre,Wrath Of God
2-Stalker
3-zerkalo
4-The Discreet Cherm of Bourgeoisie
5-Solyaris
6-Cries & Whispers
7-Jules et Jim
8-The Marriage of Maria Braun
9-Every Man for Himself and God Against All
10-the Tin Drum
11-The Holy Mountain
12-The Spirit of the Beehive

80s

1. Wings of Desire
2. Ran
3. Fitzcarraldo
4. Cinema Paradiso
5. Fanny & Alexander
6-Au Revoir Les Enfants
7-Come and See
8-Where is My Friend's House?

90s:
1-To Live
2-The Double Life of Veronique
3-three color:blue
4-All About My Mother
6-*beep* Åmål
6-Chungking Express
7-Europa Europa
8-Central do Brasil
9-Sátántangó
10-Underground
11-Ghost in the Shell
12-Europa all Lars von Trier movies are great masterpieces: Dogville,Dancer in the Dark Breaking the Waves
13-run lola run
14-Once Were Warriors
15-La haine

00s:
1-city of god
2-4 Months, 3 Weeks & 2 Days
3-Persepolis
4-Pan's Labyrinth
5-Spring, Summer, Autumn, Winter... and Spring
6-JSA
7-Turtles Can Fly
8-Let the Right One In
9-Lilja 4-ever
10-2046
11-The Brotherhood of War
12-The Motorcycle Diaries
13-Good Bye Lenin!
14-The Return
15-Frida
16-Head-On
17-Hero
18-Bad Education
19-The Blind Swordsman: Zatoichi
20-Yi yi
21-The Child
22-The Son
23-NO man's Land

reply

This isn't even among the best 250 films made in the 1960s, never mind all time.

Proud member of the Pro-film Anti-digital Society (PFADS).

reply

I agree the top 250 is largely a joke filled with way too many new movies, but that is partially just down to the fact that a film needs 25,000 votes to even be in contention for that list. A "foreign" film from the 60s is never going to get that many votes.

Just don't take the list too seriously. Good things are often unpopular and what should really matter is how you feel about a film not how random people on the internet decided to score it.

reply