MovieChat Forums > Bande à part (1964) Discussion > Marion Collitard looks exacty like Anna ...

Marion Collitard looks exacty like Anna Karina in this


I'm a big fan of Marion Colliard. I loved her in A very Long Engagement, Love Me If You Dare, and La Vie En Rose, and am very much looking forward to seeing her upcoming film Public Enemies with Bale and Depp.

Anyway, I just watched Band Of Outsiders last night for the first time and I swear that Anna Karina was Marion Collitard's mother or something. Turns out they aren't releated, but they look exactly the same.
Marions page:
http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0182839/

Oh yeah, Band Of Outsiders was great too! My second Godard film. I have Weekend coming next.

"Take comfort in knowing you never had a choice" -Vincent
http://trip66.dvdaf.com/owned

reply

[deleted]

To me Anna Karina was always the splitting image of Sylvia Sidney, an American actress from the 30s and 40s probably best known as Spencer Tracy's girlfriend in Fritz Lang's Fury. It's really in their matching sweet eyes and smile. Since most of Sidney's photos online are of her glammed up, it's easier to see the resemblance in her films when she's more natural looking, but I'll try to find similar-looking pictures:

Syliva: http://www.crazy4cinema.com/Actress/imgs/sidney.jpg
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/7/7d/Sylvia_Sidney .JPG/180px-Sylvia_Sidney.JPG

Anna: http://houseofmirthandmovies.files.wordpress.com/2008/12/karina.jpg
http://www.girishshambu.com/blog/anna-karina-1.jpg

"GOD--WAS--WRONG!"--James Mason, Bigger Than Life

reply

To me there's also a resemblance to Gene Tierney, of say, Laura and Where the Sidewalk Ends. Both films are Godard favourites and reference points in Le Petit Soldat(their first film together) and in Alphaville.

Sylvia Sidney's at her most Anna Karinian in You Only Live Once, a key influence on Pierrot le Fou.

Anna Karina's face in Vivre sa Vie also shows a key resemblance to Renee Falconetti in that most famous of Dreyer films. And of course Anna is Danish(and her mother worked on the crew of a Dreyer film once).

That's part of the mystique of the films she made with Godard, he was able to use her beauty and singular face as an iconography to summon influences and references with actresses and female figures of the past. Not just film actresses but also literary heroines and figures in paintings. And of course in Made in U.S.A., Godard made her the second coming of Humphrey Bogart, more or less.




"Ça va by me, madame...Ça va by me!" - The Red Shoes

reply

i can see the resemblance, both have very expressive eyes.. but while i was watching this movie actually she immediately reminded me of a younger Kate Moss and Lea Seydoux, especially in these pictures:

http://cdn.shopify.com/s/files/1/0036/4682/t/1/assets/blog_KateMoss.ba ckstage.MartinMargiel.S93-thumb-550x7873.jpg?3561
http://loquelvientosedejo.files.wordpress.com/2011/05/9-kate-moss-by-p eter-lindbergh-1994.jpg
http://img.zanda.com/item/98010100000039/730xauto/Kate_Moss.jpg
http://flk.cl/clientes/in-lan.com/images/201305/KateMoss-00.jpg
http://www.interviewmagazine.com/fashion/la-seydoux-by-peter-lindbergh

i was quite fascinated by Anna Karina in this, really wanna see more of her movies!
.

reply