MovieChat Forums > Bewitched (1964) Discussion > A Vision of Sugar Plums

A Vision of Sugar Plums



I realized I brought this up on the old imdb boards, but I must ask again: Am I the ONLY
one who dislikes this first Christmas outing?

I tried sitting through it Sunday night, to get my holiday viewing started. I chose this first,
mainly to get it over with. I still find it duller than dull, sluggishly paced, unfunny treacle.
The direction is so poor (Alan Rafkin), and the performances lackluster. The always
capable Billy Mumy just sleepwalks though his role (compare this to his sparkling turn as
young Darrin in season two). Alice Pearce and Montgomery are fine, but not enough to save
this dud, which is also cheap-looking, and loaded with bad special effects (love those DOLLS
flying on the tiny broom over the model house!).

The fact that all we have so far is a surviving 16 MM print doesn't help either.

Why does everyone like this one so much? I truly don[t get it.

reply

It's not a favorite of mine either. It's okay and I like Billy Mumy. I thought he was such a cute kid. But it's not a "must see" episode for me. Like you, I usually just watch it as part of my holiday viewing.

I did think it was nice that Abner and Gladys wanted to take in an orphan for the holidays. it added a dimension to them. I've often imagined my own backstory about why Gladys was such a snoop. She wanted to have a family and she and Abner tried but had no luck. So over the years, with all that extra time on her hands, she became neurotic and nosy. She became overly involved in other people's lives.

There is one funny moment when Gladys says that she's never been a mother before and Abner tells her not to get any ideas! lol

reply


It also irks me that Michael, who's been such a "problem", he's been "returned" to the orphanage twice, suddenly
gets a nice new set of parents for Christmas, while (as far as we can see), the much sweeter Tommy has to go back
to that ugly orphanage with the always-smiling-like-she's-a-Stepford-wife Mrs. Grange.

Back to the acting: Mumy rally doesn't act. AT ALL. He doesn't seem genuinely unhappy, happy, or even impressed
with Samantha's witchcraft OR Santa Claus! His reactions to everything are so blasé.

Only plus: the lovely character actor Cecil Kellaway - while wasted here - made a lovely Santa, so much more so
than the serviceable Don Beddoe and horribly miscast Ronald Long. Too bad they couldn't get Kellaway back again.

reply

It isn't my favorite either. But I do like that they show Samantha and company flying off into the night on her broom. Yeah by today's standards that special effect might be cheesy, hell it might have even been cheesy when it came out that first season...I wasn't born then to know. But I do like that scene.

reply


"I wasn't born then to know."

BITCH!!! Lol!

reply

Hahaha....sorry! ;)

reply


But at least I was only (cough cough) TWO in 1964.

reply

lol....well then you ain't that old then G. ;)

reply


And, believe it or not, I'm still quite handsome and sexy.

You're lucky you don't live in Los Angeles. :)

reply

Haha!! I'll bet you are my friend! ;)

reply

And boy gbennett, so totally humble and modest! LOL Well it's probably true anyway. All my life I've noticed that the hot good looking guys are either married or gay!

reply


I wouldn't say "I'm hot", by any standards. But I have all my hair, and I'm told I'm still handsome.
My trouble is, when I am approached, it's by a WOMAN!

Funny story: When I invited some folks I work with over for a dinner party some years back, one
woman assumed I was straight. THEN she walked in and saw my film and TV memorabilia
everywhere and GOT IT. Lol!

reply

LOL, well you did say that your neighbor used to call you that "sissy kid" or something similar. HE "got it".

It's not always an accident though. I have been attracted to some gay men myself. They always dress so well, look so good and you can actually talk to them! Straight men can be such @sses!!

reply


Yes, I guess I was more obvious as a kid, but the neighbors all knew my taste, as I was
always knocking on their doors to watch old movies when our set was broken down.

reply