Today it would be odd with big screen televisions where you would see Melanie's face very clearly.
Today it would be odd with the internet. If it was a new show and that happened it would probably crash the internet with many fans of the show rushing to the forums/Twitter/Facebook to say they saw Samantha's double and oh isn't it funny, slack, lazy, amateur, fantastic (etc etc) of the producers to let that one go?
But back then I don't think it would've been odd. Melanie was probably a nice actress and they wanted to show their appreciation by showing her face on screen even in only for a second. You know, as a sign of respect or something of that sort.
Also back then not many people would've noticed as not many knew there was sometimes two different actresses on screen rather than a split screen.
Also with televisions having very small screens back then, I don't think it would have been too noticeable to notice it wasn't Samantha's face but her double's. reply share
But here's something really odd. I just found out that being a stand in can be a career move which I think of as rather odd. Don't you? If I am to believe the imdb entry for Melanie/Melody, she was not only a stand in for Elizabeth Montgomery all those years ago in early 1970s, she was also stand in for Goldie Hawn in the early 1990s!? http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0566386/?ref_=ttfc_fc_cr20
There was NO way they "wanted" to show Melody's face, for heaven's sake. But you're correct that with the lower resolution of TVs then, they just did a quick shot. And Liz really mugs it up in that tag, trying to draw the attention to SAM.
The "Oops, there's Melody" thing happened several times. In season six's "Serena Stops the Show", Sam and Serena enter the living room to greet Darrin and Larry. Today, all you have to do is hit "pause" and Melody's face is seen briefly, but clearly.
In season seven's "Darrin Goes Ape", Sam (Montgomery) "changes" into Serena in the hallway, as Darrin works in the den. It is obvious that Melody simply takes over as Serena, to save time.
The effects on BW were primitive - even during its original run. But who watches the show to be dazzled by the effects? "Charmed" has much better effects, but isn't nearly as charming a series.
I wonder if they planned to do a horizontal split screen with that closing shot, but ran out of time or money (or they just didn't care). I've always been interested to see what the actual budgets for seasons and episodes were, and how much was for effects.