About the ending - SPOILERS


So... Did Tane really betray Zatoichi? Was the dying Samurai lying or telling the truth?

Show me the holes!

reply

I thought he was lying. While in the house Tane was the one that convinced the samurai to leave him alone. She might have just changed her mind, but there is no indication that she would have set it up. Although she does seem to have become much more bitter in this film.

reply

I rewatched it and I still couldn't be sure. I guess it's one of those questions that the director intentionally made it ambiguous.

Show me the holes!

reply

He was lying, Tane most definitely didn't help setup the ambush.

When she was pleading with the samurai she began to pull his sword from it's scabbard (without thinking, I believe) because she was desperate, forced to choose she would have rather seen her man dead than Zatoichi. That's why he killed her and that's why he lied to Zatoichi. Jealously, hate, sadness, revenge, love, so many reasons to hurt Zatoichi and his memory of Tane, and to hurt Tane further even though she'd never be able to know it.

[edit] Typos

reply

I don't know... I think it's quite a jump from her pulling out the sword accidentally to her wanting her man dead rather than Zatoichi.

May be I will ask my Japanese friends to explain that to me. There may be some cultural insight which I am not getting.

Show me the holes!

reply

I don't know... I think it's quite a jump from her pulling out the sword accidentally to her wanting her man dead rather than Zatoichi.

imo it was the closest they could do next to her actually saying it, which would kill both the poetry and the realism. Tane's frantic pleading for them to leave, grabbing and beginning to unsheath the sword before suddenly realising what she'd done, him looking at the sword and then killing her. I'm not sure what else you'd need in there for the meaning to be clear. Her hand wanted to kill the samurai.

reply


As others have replied, Otane did not betray Zatoichi. As Tanakura was dying, he said it was Otane in a last attempt to hurt Zatoichi. In reality, it was Sakichi who set Zatoichi up.

I just watched the new Criterion release, and it supposedly has new and improved subtitles, so perhaps the original DVD releases had subtitles that were more ambiguous. But even without better subtitles, just look at Otane's face when she see's Zatoichi and realizes Tanakura was going to kill him, and you'll realize that there's no way it was her. Therefore, it's surprising how even the essay that accompanies the Criterion boxed set, written by film scholar Geoffrey O'Brien, got it wrong. He writes: "...he meets...Otane, who (in Zatoichi the Fugitive) betrays him, even as Zatoichi persists in refusing to credit her betrayal." It's a shame O'Brien wrote that, because Otane truly loved Zatoichi, and her character, which was featured in two films, was one of the most well developed women in the entire series.

Below is the new and improved Criterion subtitles and a description of the scene for anyone who still needs convincing.

It begins with a scene where Sakichi says to Zatoichi, “You know a woman called Otane? She’s been caught by Yagiri. They’re using her as a decoy to lure the samurai to their side.” Sakichi then leads Zatoichi to a dilapidated building.

When Zatoichi enters the building with Sakichi, Otane gasps in surprise “Master Ichi!” The camera holds on her as she looks completely stunned with her mouth agape, then the camera pans to Tanakura, who says “Good work” to Sakichi. Zatoichi says, “So that’s what it is. The trap is for me. Otane, are you with them too?” Otane replies, “No, no!” as she shuffles in his direction, with no indication whatsoever of being less than 100% sincere. In the same shot, she immediately spins around to grab Tanakura by the lapel, distressed, exclaiming, “Why are you doing this?” He tosses her aside, saying, “Ichi, be happy. The price on your head is up to 300 ryo. The one who offered the prize is Sakichi here.” He goes on to say, “It bothers me that you’re alive. Understand?” The two square off, and as soon as Tanakura puts his hand on the hilt of his sword, Otane cries, “Wait!” in an attempt to stop him. But then Yagiri shows up outside the building with his men. Tanakura yells out to him, “I’m taking the 300!” implying he is going to be the one to kill Zatoichi. Once again, Otane runs up to him, saying, “Stop. Please, stop! Please stop,” and, this time, successfully gets him to reconsider. Tanakura yells to Yagiri, “Okay, do it (i.e., kill Zatoichi) if you can. I’ll stand here and watch.”

reply

That ending was really ambiguous, I guess this thread cleared some things.

reply