MovieChat Forums > X (1963) Discussion > What Did He See at The End? -SPOILERS

What Did He See at The End? -SPOILERS




SPOILERS-

A long time ago, I read a friend's comic book of X.

If memory serves me correct, I recall, in the final scene, that he looks up and sees bizarre flying creatures from another dimension, which brought to mind Lovecraft's Elder Gods.

Then he sees (or thinks he sees) the Eye of God.

Then he 'plucks it out'.

Now, those creatures were not in the film, obviously due to its limited budget.

Is there anyone who recalls the comic book of X? And, if so, do they have even vague recollections of them?

This film still freaks me out. And I do remember hearing of the alternate ending where he screams "I can still see'" If that clipped footage still exists, they should rerelease it with it included. Or just include both versions for the benefit of squirmers.

I hesitate to imagine how much that comic book would be worth today.



reply

I don't know of any comic book, Deluge, but I do recall a rumor (or urban legend maybe) that the original ending of X has the doctor, after pulling his eyes out of their sockets, crying out "I can still see!".

Apparently, so the story goes, this was considered "too much" for 1963 moviegoers, so it was edited out. I'm not sure if I believe the story but it's fun (and scary) to think about. It strikes me as a bit much for a 1963 studio picture, even a programmer, but then so is Dementia 13 in its entirety.

reply

Oh hell yeah. Now how did it go? "There are great darknesses coming to devour us all! They are larger than the stars, larger than the *galaxies* of stars! They are *coming!*" That did a serious number on my nine-year-old mind. The illustration showed big amorphous, vaguely bat-like black voids in the cosmos, which only made it creepier.

Maybe it's having only seen the movie when I was much, much older, but the comic book was much more effective to me. While I'm a champion of the low budget, sometimes you need quality special effects - apart from the cocktail-napkin-humor 'naked party' scene, Milland's visions looked like what I imagine glaucoma to be like. I would be okay with, even welcome, a modern CGI remake - and I never thought I'd use that line.

reply





YOU NAILED IT!

I had those same disturbing memories of those bat-like creatures which brought Lovecraft to mind. Wonder if they were in the original script, which Corman had to cut out due to the limited budget. Seems no one else recalls that.

I'm sure it was a Gold Key Comic Book, which must now be worth a small fortune. I remember their TWILIGHT ZONE Comics, and the stories were even scarier, more like THRILLER or WAY OUT. I wonder why they were never adapted.

Believe that Gold Key also had THRILLER which later became BORIS KARLOFF'S TALES OF MYSTERY.

I agree about the overuse of CGI, but it pains me a bit to honestly admit that, if used right, would enhance a remake. Would the creatures be used? The problem is that they were brought in within the final frames, introducing a further plot elemnet, but were abruptly dismissed after the eye plucking finale.

However, it leaves you with the frightened feeling that worse events could follow. Another nightmare to have to sleep with.

Many of the Comics from that era (TALES TO ASTONISH, STRANGE TALES, AMAZING ADVENTURES) all had some truly terrifying stories that were never adapted. Back then they couldn't do the FX, but now it's a different story. With all the endless complaints about remakes, reboots, and Hollywood lacking originality, it makes me wonder why someone hasn't picked up on those possibilities. As long as they aren't mishandled in that campy, condescending way like CREEPSHOW or TALES FROM THE CRYPT.

Much depends on who owns the legal rights, but there is a potential Gold (Key?) Mine.


reply

http://templeofschlock.blogspot.co.nz/2009/04/x-man-with-x-ray-eyes-comic-book.html

A few of the pages are on that blog.

reply



Good Show!

I'll check it. Wonder if the comic was ever republished. That ending by itself could make for a hell of a story, but today it would be CGI crazy.

Another Hollywood Lovecraft Tragedy.


reply

Wow those comics sound awesome. i want

reply

Here's the comic book:

http://www.comics.org/series/1612/

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

I read the comic book and have dim memories of the final scene.

Years later I saw the movie on a black and television, back in the previus millennium. I don't know if I could see anything at all of his final vision on the black & white tv. I considered it to be be a let down from what I remebered from the comic book's ending.

I saw the movie again for the second time on Sat. NOv. 12, 2022 on color tv. I could see the final vision much clearer, It was now a scene in different colors instead of shades of gray. But I just saw some rather abstract colors and patterns. They didn't seem very terrifying to me. They looked like they could rather normal deoration that nobody would mind.

When Xavier describes in the movie the blackness and beyond it an eye it reminded me of old ideas of cosmology.

The ancients belived the sky was an actual physical roof. Thus the Bible describes a solid firmamentabove the Earth, with trap doors in it which God opened to let the waters above pour down for the Deluge.

And the ancient greeks and Romans & the medievals, believed the Earth, the Sun, the Moon and the planets all floated inside a hollow sphere which had glowing lights, the stars, attached to the inside. And beyond that sphere where the heavens of God, the angels, and the saints.

Thus some Ancient, and Medieval, and Baroque, and Rococo domes and vaults were decorated with images of a blue daylight sky with clouds, or a black night sky with stars, and at the top and center an actual hole in the sky dome would be depicted revealing the heavens beyond the sky dome.

And Xavier's desriptin sort of reminds me of that decorative scheme. Only perhaps Xavier was seeing not two levels of reality but more. A higher (& farther) reality beyond the physical reality of other space and some other even higher (& farther) reality beyond and a yet higher (& farther) reality beyond that, and so on, up to some ultimate glory or horror.

reply

Here is a link to aquestion and answer about the different endings of the comic and the film.

https://scifi.stackexchange.com/questions/269430/the-comic-book-version-of-x-the-man-with-the-x-ray-eyes-1963

reply