Modern Remake


I know it's a blasphemous thing to bring up, but the whole time I was watching the film, I was thinking how fun it would be to see Elijah Wood take on the lead role in a remake.

Who else do you think would be good in a modern remake? I could only come up with actors that I really liked for a couple others.

Josef - Elijah Wood or James Franco

The Advocate - Ricky Gervais (it is supposed to be a comedy, granted a black comedy) or John Goodman

Leni - Marion Cotillard or Rachel Weisz

Titorelli, Block and Uncle Karl would all be very fun comedic roles too, but I haven't been able to think of anyone that fits in my mind...

reply

[deleted]

How about a young Stephen Colbert as K?

Or if we could go back in time, Michael J Fox.

I think K should be played by someone less than 30 years old and who comes across as respectable yet who is harboring an inner rebel.

reply



Sir Garey Coleman as K?


Garey "Cheeks" Coleman played Orson in a Biscuit Bro. commercial (85)! They dressed him up as old plump Kane.

Fun Factoid: Garey suffered a "brunch injury" two days into the shoot. He
never recovered.





reply

Franco as K. is an interesting idea, but I really think Norton would be a better choice. Franco seems too pretty-boyish, while Norton has a thin, sickly look which I think suits the character better.

Can't add much else, I've never thought of anyone else being these characters.

reply

Terry Gilliam's remake is the best remake ever made. Brazil might not be a shot-for shot remake, but it's clever adaptation updates & introduces many new themes (gender roles, consumerism).

reply

Does anyone know if Gilliam was actively influenced by The Trial, or whether it was more of an indirect influence? Seeing The Trial, it is hard not to believe Gilliam could not have been aware of it when he made Brazil.

reply

Yes he was.

Brazil was probably my favorite as a teen in the 80s. So when I saw The Trial for the first time after it had been restored & made the art house circuit 10 - 15 yrs ago, Brazil came instantly to mind. In particular, the scene where he is walking by many desks at his workplace to talk to his boss is almost identical to the workplace scene in Brazil. My suspicions were confirmed when I saw an interview with Gilliam (maybe in the Criterion 3 disc supplements) where he mentions The Trial.

reply

"Brazil" definitely includes ideas and images from both the book and the film of "The Trial". It also loosely follows the storyline of "1984" (indeed, the original title was supposedly "1984 1/2"). The whole film is full of little references to other films, in keeping with Terry Gilliam's tendency to stuff the frame with a bit of everything.

I remember seeing "Brazil" when it first came out and being completely blown away. It doesn't see, quite so fresh any more, with so many parts of it being lifted by others (one even hears the song fairly often!), but it's quite an accomplishment. With the mixing of elements from throughout the 20th Century, "Brazil" was made to keep the viewer off-balance from the first frame, and a century from now, I suspect it will still have the same effect.

It would have been interesting indeed if Gilliam had had the budget (or at least modern CGI) to make the film as originally scripted (full shooting script can be found in "The Battle Of Brazil"). Large sequences were left unfilmed which would have added still more layers to the story. On the other hand, if everything had been filmed....I expect the result would have been four hours long.

If anyone has not had the chance and can find a way, do get a copy of the European cut or the Criterion version of "Brazil". It's 12 minutes longer than the American cut (largely due to the removal of two scenes which aren't that big a deal), but the overall pacing and the number of little "tidbits" that were snipped from the American version are a delight to discover.

The last resort of one who cannot think is to argue that another cannot feel.

reply

Does anyone hold the rights for an adaption or is Kafka's work like Shakespeare in that anyone can adapt it?

reply

What about Kyle Mcglocklin... OH, wait...they did re make it with him

reply

Yeah, with terrible results.

reply

In some ways The Cube reminds me of a modern, commercial reworking of The Trial. I know which film I prefer.

reply

I'm thinking maybe,

David Tennant or Martin Freeman for Josef
Anthony Hopkins as the advocate or James Earl Jones

reply

[deleted]

KEVIN ZEGERS OR EMILE HIRSCH
THE ADVOCATE ROBERT DE NIRO
LENI - JENA MALONE OR KELLI GARNER

reply