MovieChat Forums > The Great Escape (1963) Discussion > McCallum on the train: cool under pressu...

McCallum on the train: cool under pressure or flubbed line?


OK, so British airmen are on the train, escaping thru German territory, in the middle of a lot of Germans. Not only do they have to answer questions in German, but to do so with a convincing accent. The scene where the Gestapo guys are going thru the train, randomly asking for papers & questioning people, I observed this: 1 of the Gestapo asks David McCallum why he's travelling? He says "fur meine..." and then a full 3 seconds goes by, and he starts over, says "fur meine geschaft [for my business]". It looked to me like the actor simply had trouble memorizing them 3 words - and if his character's a native German, wouldn't that odd speech characteristic tip off the Gestapo guy? The other possibility is that he's playing it cool - he's a German on legitimate business, so he's so nonchalant he even talks...breezy. Does any1 else who saw this scene see this, and what do u think?

reply

I always thought Eric was pretty sophisticated- almost aristocratic. I think he did it on purpose.

reply

Ducky wouldn't make that kind of mistake.

108 193 23 8114 246* 47.73 22 42

reply

There were thousands of foreign workers in Germany by then and most of them spoke faltering German at best, the escapees simply didn't pose as native born Germans unless they had lived there and were completely fluent and could pass as native Germans.

Trust me. I know what I'm doing.

reply

I noticed this too, but he paused only long enough to pull out his card, which I suspect validated his story.

"I'm travelling for my....for my (pull out card) business".

reply

McCallum is a professional, and I'm certain he memorized this three-word line thoroughly. "The Great Escape" was a big-budget production, and if he had made a mistake the director most certainly would have had him do it over.

reply

Most people pause when asked a question by security forces. They still do this at some airports. If your answer seems practiced it tips them off.

So playing it cool.

reply