MovieChat Forums > Charade (1963) Discussion > Oh, I hate it when...

Oh, I hate it when...


The most unrealistic thing in movies is when the woman's ENTIRE belongings fit in a couple of very light suitcases that she can easily carry. Then, as if by magic, we later spot her in an array of outfits which simply couldn't have come from those two suitcases.

Reggie returns from the ski trip with two really light suitcases that she carries with one hand. She takes them upstairs to reveal an empty apartment. But she is later shown in different well-matching clothes even though she confesses she has no money.

I think movies should at least show a picture of a moving van. Even stock footage will do.

reply

I would assume she had several outfits in her suitcases. She must have changed her outfits on holiday at a smart ski resort.

reply

She was a rich and affluent woman, good chance she had a line of credit at the high-end fashion stores. But also, didn't her sister live in Paris also? Sisters loan each other clothes even on days when one of them hasn't been widowed with only a suitcase or two to her name.

Why do people so frequently get told to read the book on a movie database?

reply

didn't her sister live in Paris also?

I don't recall anything in the movie about a sister.



Don't mess with me, man! I know karate, judo, ju-jitsu..... and several other Japanese words.

reply

Oh, I got the impression Sylvie was her sister. I'm sure she was referred to as aunt Reggie to Jean-Louis a few times.

Why do people so frequently get told to read the book on a movie database?

reply

As I understand it, Reggie (Audrey Hepburn's character) is supposed to be an American woman married to a Swiss (Charles Lampert, the guy who was murdered on the train). Sylvie is a French woman. She (Sylvie) is not Reggie's sister, she is a co-worker and friend of Reggie's at "EURESCO" where they had both worked as simultaneous translators. Sylvie's boy called Reggie "aunt" I believe only one time, not because Reggie is his aunt, but just in an endearing fashion. (Also, I've read several synopses of the movie, and they all name Sylvie as Reggie's friend, not sister).

Dialogue from the script:
Peter Joshua - What are you going to do?
Reggie - Try and get my old job back at EURESCO, I suppose.
Peter Joshua - Doing what?
Reggie - I'm a simultaneous translator, like Sylvie. Only she's English into French, and I'm French into English. That's what I was doing before I met Charles.



Don't mess with me, man! I know karate, judo, ju-jitsu..... and several other Japanese words.

reply

It's common in many cultures for a child to refer to friends of parents as "Aunt" or "Uncle". Even in America this happens from time to time!

reply

Hmmm....good point! 

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen 🎇

reply

Actually, a woman having an endless wardrobe in two small suitcases in one of the reasons that movies are much better than real life. If I want real life I can look around my own house for free and see dishes stacked in the sink. It's much more fun to see glamorous people in great clothes driving amazing cars. If Hollywood made a movie about me you'd have a leading man who drives to work in a twenty year old truck and sits in a cubicle handling calls to and from shareholders. Work five days a week, church on Wednesday and Sunday, go to Wal-Mart with the family on Saturday and maybe a movie that night. I'd have a hard time imagine anyone hiring a baby sitter, driving to the mall, and paying cash money to see that movie. 😀

reply

Of course movies aren't realistic. 

But still...grr...she can get an endless wardrobe into only a couple of small suitcases!  I couldn't do that.

~~~~~
Jim Hutton (1934-79) & Ellery Queen

reply

Some women must manage that. I remember reading Leni Reifestahl's autobiography, in which she recounted that American soldiers took all her possessions and threw her in a jail cell. She was left with nothing but the clothes on her back and her working print of Tiefland. After release, another group of American soldiers took all her possessions and threw in jail. She was left with nothing but the clothes on her back and her working print of Tiefland ...

reply

When Inspector Grandpierre returns her husband’s belonging to her, they included a wallet with 4,000 francs. Accounting for the conversion rate and inflation, that is about $6,800 in 2020. That could purchase and “array of outfits” perhaps

reply

I mean she wasn't exactly on Gilligan's Island and somehow the Howell's and Ginger had all those outfits there. OP wanted to see a moving van?! Get real! Anyway, this was one of my favorite films, I may rewatch it now! By the way I did a conversion and 4000 1963 Francs was 817 1963 dollars and 5353 2015 dollars. Not sure about 2020.

reply

She obviously bought those outfits while on vacation. Maybe I'm showing my age, but this was a cliche back then. When women traveled to Paris, they were always shown going on massive buying sprees.

reply

People had smaller wardrobes in those days. I know an older lady who said that around that time, both she and her husband fit all their hanging clothes into one wardrobe, you know, those free-standing cabinet wardrobes that went out when proper closets started getting built into all homes, and which offered about three feet of hanger space? People had a few good clothes then and were perfectly fine with wearing the same clothes all the time. A man might have one good suit, and maybe a different suit for sundays or special occasions, a raincoat and/or an overcoat, and he'd change his shirt and underthings. A woman might have one good suit too, and a couple of summer dresses and a couple of winter dresses and some skirts and blouses and a winter coat and a rain coat, and she'd wear them with various scarves, hats, gloves, and shoes, to vary her outfits a little.

I read a biography of President Kennedy a long time ago, and this discussion made me remember that Jacqueline Kennedy, the premiere fashion plate of the early 1960s, would live out of one suitcase for weeks on end when her husband was on the campaign trail. She'd have a couple of good day outfits (perhaps a couple of suits and some blouses), and one cocktail dress and one formal dress for the events she had to attend. Of course, that was before the press recorded every damn thing famous people wore, and mocked them for wearing the same thing twice.

reply