Guests arrive twice?



After i watched the film I read a few critiques of it that say, at the beginning of the film the guests arrive twice. When does that happen? When I watched it back all is I can see are the guests congregating near the front door then when the two female servants attempt to leave the guests walk through the front door. The servants wait for the guests to go upstairs and then leave through the front door.

reply

It does happen, and at first I thought that there had been an editing mistake (they do and say the exact same things), but then the maid servants leave after the second entrance.

Another glitch of the Matrix... I mean, another deja vu occurrence happens at the dinner table, when the host makes a toast to a virgin girlfriend or some such, but the other characters' reactions vary from one toast to the other.

And since they had to re-enact the end of their night to get out of the house, the double entrance makes sense. The cycle had to be completed.

reply

Hmmm. The version shown on Turner Classic Movies cuts the second entrance.

The sequence begins at 0:04:10 in the version posted here...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RYqH2eTcm4c

reply

The version i watched has the second arrival cut as well. It's such a crucial scene so spoils the film a bit.

I thought i was being stupid. Thank you so much.

reply

Holy craaaaap!

I watched it on Hulu and had paused it at both those parts. When the scenes repeated I just thought Hulu had kindly ewinded a few seconds.

i remember thinking about the toast, that he'd received a different reaction.

Great!

reply

Ha! I watched it on Hulu and for whatever reason I happened to have paused it twice. When they enter and the toast scene. I thought Hulu was helpfully rewinding a few seconds, but I remember thinking how weird the reception to the toast was. It was different bc it was the second time! Intriguing.

reply

Nice double, deja vu post there.

reply

There's a conversation about the fact they enter twice and how Buñuel explained it to the actors here with this interesting clip of an interview with Silvia Pinal from the new Criterion DVD....

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=59wYabRQpm8

reply

there's a few moments that happen twice.
27 to be exact.

reply