Please release this on DVD


I'd seen this movie on tv before but it's been almost 20 years and I recorded it on VHS, but the quality has deteriorated quite a bit. I would be so happy if the film studio would restore the film with its vibrant colors and release it on DVD. This movie is a holiday classic and I would love to see it on dvd as I'm sure all of you reading this. Another holiday classic that deserves a dvd release is the Adventures of Tom Sawyer with Tommy Kelly, the 1938 version and to me the best version. I haven't seen that played on tv in about 20 years as well.

reply

I suggest you run out out and buy the new edition of HOW THE WEST WAS WON, and write Warner Brothers Home Video. They need to get a very strong indication of interest for this title before they can consider spending their money on it.

reply

The restoration of Wonderful World of Brothers Grimm is probably impossible. The original Cinerama camera negatives were badly damaged in a warehouse fire. Unlike How the West was Won, this film was never transferred to a 70mm version so today the only version that exists is a very poor 35mm composite version. This version is not the roadshow version of the film, the color is badly faded and the side panels, A and C are cut off. A DVD version would not be very good based on what surviving elements they have to work with.

reply

HTWWW is in good shape because those 3-strip Cinerama negatives were NOT damaged. It has nothing to do with a 70mm version being done.

I was told by someone who oversaw both properties that a restoration of WWOTBC would be very expensive, but he did not say that it was impossible.

reply

[deleted]

I don't know how they did it but TCM has restored it. They showed it this weekend. The complete roadshow version. And it looked beautiful. And they didn't advertise it on their website!!!???!!! I ran into it while I was surfing channels. So there is no reason they couldn't release a DVD.

reply

No one would like more than me to see it given the kind of treatment, attention and exposure that HOW THE WEST WAS WON has received, However...

Nobody "restored" anything. Unless someone can do a comparison with the laserdisc, it seems likely that's the same version that's been playing for years, complete with the join lines and bent horizon. Didn't the laserdisc have the overture and entracte and some sound for the missing prologue? The visual for the prologue has turned up in the TCM transfer years ago. I would love to think they re-transfered the whole movie but even if they did, It is it nothing near a literal "restoration."

The few empowered enthusiasts who are involved with Cinerama really don't think much of it as a movie. Check out all the coverage on Cinerama online, even the documentary, and it's barely given a mention.

reply

It would be great if Hollywood restored some of these classics rather than do remaksSource:Movie Reviews Wonderful Worldhttp://moviereviews.noskram.com/2010/06/movie-reviews-wonderful-world

reply

I have a feeling this will eventually get released on DVD via Warner Archives. They've released other George Pal movies such as ATLANTIS, THE LOST CONTINENT and THE POWER. Just curious as to why this has not been available considering it was Pal's biggest production.

reply

Here's the latest on that:

Updated info available on Wikipedia...

Rumors of the original 3 strip Cinerama negatives being extensively water damaged are enormously exaggerated. It's recently been reported that the actual damage is minimal - just the far edge of one panel and only in some scenes. Further, WB pointed out that they still have the B&W Technicolor separations for the entire film, so they could replace the entire negative if they needed to, but they don't.

That's the good news. Bad news is the math: mastering this film from 3 strip is very expensive, replacing the few damaged negative parts still involves 3 color sep reels for that one Cinerama panel. Further, this film is less known and popular than How The West Was Won and we are still in a recession. Therefore due to cost a first rate video transfer of the film does not seem likely for now.

In order to be released on Warner's MOD Archive DVD program, they would need to be able to transfer the film to video fairly cheaply...

Since the laserdisc was apparently mastered (like 20 years ago) from a 35mm composite print of the general release version, it was missing the short prologue, plus Overture, Intermission and Exit Music. The audio for all these parts has been readily available, and was just included on a 2 CD soundtrack album.

At some point Turner Classic Movies began broadcasting what some believed to be a "restored" version, as it has the Overture, Entr'Acte and Exit Music played over a still shot, and the 79 second battle prologue is now visible. This in no way constitutes a restoration. A comparison of the TCM broadcast with the laserdisc and the actual picture has been posted here: http://cinerama.topcities.com/wwotbgld.htm

It has been recently reported that there is also a 65mm composite negative that could conceivably be transferred to video at much lower cost than the 3 strip negatives.

A petition to release WONDERFUL WORLD OF THE BROTHERS GRIMM on DVD/BluRay has been posted online at: http://www.change.org/petitions/warner-brothers-home-video-please-release-the-wonderful-world-of-the-brothers-grimm-on-dvd-and-blu-ray

Even better, you could send your request writing (on paper) to:
Warner Home Video - 4000 Warner Blvd - Burbank, CA 91522
(every physical letter counts more than a hundred electric ones)

Finally, an archival IB Technicolor print of the original 3 strip Cinerama roadshow version is reportedly planned to show this Spring at Bradford, and this Fall in Hollywood, thanks to a collector in Australia named John Mitchell.

reply

Thanks for that info CineSight. Very informative. I should have realized that the costs would be enormous in terms of restoration.

Since this year marks the 50th anniversary of this film, I'm glad they are planning roadshows, and may catch the one playing in Hollywood.

reply

It has recently been mentioned that there is also a 65mm negative that contains all 3 panels, so the cost isn't necessarily as astronomical as previously thought. Full details on wikipedia.

A petition to release WONDERFUL WORLD OF THE BROTHERS GRIMM on DVD/BluRay has been posted online at: http://www.change.org/petitions/warner-brothers-home-video-please-release-the-wonderful-world-of-the-brothers-grimm-on-dvd-and-blu-ray

Even better, you could send your request writing (on paper) to:
Warner Home Video - 4000 Warner Blvd - Burbank, CA 91522
(every physical letter counts more than a hundred electric ones)

reply