MovieChat Forums > What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? (1962) Discussion > Madonna would be good as 'Baby Jane' if ...

Madonna would be good as 'Baby Jane' if there was to be a remake

posted 11 years ago by cameronjtshaw
14 replies | jump to latest

I think she would be fantastic as Baby Jane if there ever to be a remake. Granted her track record in films isn't great, I think she would suit that role perfectly.

[–] cjenkin6 11 years ago

Who do you think would be a good Blanche?

[–] intercambioderemixes 11 years ago

Madonna is too hot and young for that role.

[–] superlustfulamanda94 11 years ago

She's about the same age as the Joan Crawford and Bette Davis were at that time.

[–] summerishere77 11 years ago

No, just no.

[–] cookiela2001 11 years ago

She's a borderline wretched actress. So my vote is a no.

[–] SimplemindedSociety 10 years ago

'She's a borderline wretched actress. So my vote is a no'.
----------------
cookie,
I have to ask: would she be appraised as such is not for being "Madonna"? She has received decent reviews for some films.

[–] andy-todd-1 11 years ago

I think Tonya Harding and Nanci Kerrigan would work well!

[–] smt-cool156 10 years ago

She's more of a singer than an actress, so...no.

[–] CGlMDB 10 years ago

If only Madonna would go away like the characters in the film both did....

[–] 10 years ago

[deleted]

[–] Foster (876) a year ago

Well, 10 years ago when this thread started id say she could look the part, BUT since she's had to much plastic surgery AND hasn't the talent

[–] jcnyclv (1382) a year ago

I actually think she'd be great, especially since she's had plastic surgery that, IMO, makes her look sort of scary. You're right, her acting is atrocious but I think she could pull off an eerie, psychotic lady very well.

[–] OnanTheBarbarian (10267) a year ago

Well, as you say, the thread is from 10 years ago. Now it would be too close to Madonna's real life as an older superstar trying to recapture her youth. She would never take such a role since she won't even admit to herself that she's no longer the youthful Material Girl.