MovieChat Forums > Hell Is for Heroes (1962) Discussion > Not a great WW2 film/Combat TV series

Not a great WW2 film/Combat TV series


Everyone has an opinion; mine is this was disappointing. In the action sequences, soldiers would routinely fall without being shot, each screaming, " Ah!" That said, the gut wound/death scene was strong. I like McQueen in an action role but in this film he was nothing special. His final act of heroism had no feeling of redemption to it, no spark of selfless humanity. I did like his scene with the female barkeeper when he spoke to her in German. I too, saw and felt the similarities with the great "Combat" TV series. I own all the DVDs of this show. "Hills are for Heroes" is one of their best. With "Combat" though, you cared about Hanley's men and understood their characters. Reese did not have an ounce of compassion for his men, unlike Saunders. Comedy consisted of Kirby's one-liners, not a stand-up routine.

reply

McQueen's Reese was supposed to be a man at home only on a battlefield. COMBAT! often featured episodes about such characters...but just about always they get killed and/or are not especially sympathetic figures.

reply

I haven't seen Combat for quite along time.I know Hell's writer Robert Pirosh worked on both productions, but I thought HIFH had a lot more cynical feel than much of Combat.

reply

Too bad you don't appreciate this anti-war film directed by the great Don Siegel on a shoe-string budget with an excellent cast and script. "Hell Is For Heroes" is NOT "Combat". Reese is not Sgt. Saunders.

reply

It`s pretty average compared to "Battleground" and "Attack" although I agree that the stomach wound is a superb sequence.

reply

It was much grimmer than those:

Coburn getting his arm blown off by a mine & then incinerated by his own flamethrowner when it detonates...and at the end, where at very high cost that pillbox gets blown up in a suicide move by McQueen--and THEN, even with that bunker being knocked out, scores of allied soldiers continue to be gunned down by other pillboxes as the movie cuts to credit.





Why can't you wretched prey creatures understand that the Universe doesn't owe you anything!?

reply