Elvis is an plagiarist...


Elvis is an plagiarist...

He doesnt know to play the guitar properly...

He hasnt written one song in his whole life..


The real songwriter deserves the name fame and money!!!


why cant u people see that.

reply

Why can't you see that Elvis did write some of his songs or co-wrote them. Plus, whether he wrote something or not, without him nobody would have written anything because there never would have been Rock N Roll. So either way he is and was important/vital.

Before Elvis, there was nothing - John Lennon

Without Elvis none of us would have made it- Buddy Holly


GAME OVER!

reply

[deleted]

So you're saying Elvis is bad cause he didn't write songs? Does that make an actor bad cause he didn't direct or write the films he acted in? Besides, the post below you answers your question if you don't like my answer.

reply

...a plagiarist.

reply

It's a well-known fact that songwriters earn more money than vocalists. If anything, Elvis Presley made a lot of songwriters wealthier.

(for comparison, one of the ABBA vocalists has around $5,000,000, while her ex-husband the songwriter has around $100,000,000).

Plus, nobody complained about Dean Martin, Darlene Love or Mama Cass not writing their own songs. As with these three vocalists, it was Elvis Presley abilities as a singer that made him famous (plus, he really did sing differently to many white singers before him. With no dis-respect intended, vocalists like Dinah Shore and Bing Crosby tended to sing very "cold" and distanced from the lyrical subject).


"The porpoise is laughing, goodbye, goodbye!.."

reply

Boy,i really miss the petty point here;

Elvis is ELVIS : one of a kind !

Forget the guitar playing or composing-he's a PERFORMER replete w\all the charisma you could wish for !

Got IT !

reply

Interestingly, I just saw a program about Dolly Parton. Elvis wanted to record her first 'hit' song. She was all excited. But when manager Col. Tom explained to her that she would have to split the song-writing credit with Elvis, she had a fit and walked out. He explained that it was common practice. Elvis was a star maker. If you wanted a huge boost in your songwriting career, you signed. You would make up for it on the next songs.
But Dolly would have none of it. She didn't sign. (she also started her own company when few women Country were allowed to be more than decoration on stage. And NONE were allowed to own their own music!)

As for Elvis - he had a unique sound and style. He changed the music of his era, like the Beatles did for mine. He likely wasn't much of a guitarist, wasn't a serious actor, and his life became a mess, consumed by pills and sex. But when you become famous or wealthy, the demons come out. The normal constraints of life don't hold them back.

But give him his credit - his singing and delivery were spectacular. If you weren't of that era, you wouldn't understand his aura.
(and look up the meaning of plagiarist!)

reply

You should know the meaning of your terminology before you accuse someone of plagiarizing. Plagiarism is the wrongful appropriation and purloining and publication of another author's language, thoughts, ideas, or expressions, and the representation of them as one's own original work.

You are assuming that Elvis found a song, recorded it without the true songwriter's permission, and then told everyone he wrote it. I am sure the song writer signed a contract allowing him to sing it, and most likely made some money as well. Songwriter's sell their songs to artists, they don't just get stolen.

Most famous singers get their songs from professional songwriters. They don't always write them themselves.

reply

Good points, although I would say the majority of artists these days write their own songs, except for country singers. Even so, there's still a large number of pop and rock vocalists or musicians who don't write their own songs and rely on songs written by independent songwriters. What has changed these days is that the non-songwriting artists don't have their own music publishing companies, which was not the case with Elvis. In the 1960s, his music publishing companies held the copyrights on more than 2000 songs.

As far as Elvis's skills as a musician, he played acoustic or electric guitar, starting with his Sun recordings (acoustic guitar) and continuing through the early 60s, when the movie songs started becoming substandard. He also played acoustic guitar and piano on his American Sound studio sessions, not on every song but more than one might think. And he continued to play guitar, though sporadically, on his 70s albums. Elvis also played bass, the last time in 1976 on one of his versions of "Blue Eyes Crying in the Rain." And according to DJ Fontana, Elvis also played the drums on one of his songs. And as for his expertise as a guitarist, his lead guitarist, James Burton said he wasn't a great guitarist but added he was a good guitarist, better than people gave him credit for being.

And on the songwriting issue, Red West, said a few years ago he believed Elvis was capable of writing his own songs. And perhaps the reason he didn't is that Elvis's manager, Col. Parker, kept Elvis so busy, he didn't have a lot of time to sit down and write songs. He did write two with Red, "That's Someone You Never Forget" (about his mother) and "You'll Be Gone" (with Charlie Hodge helping to write the latter). Ironically, the one person who caused Elvis to lose interest in trying to write his own songs was Priscilla. She was dismissive of the two above songs, thinking Elvis should've been writing rock songs, not ballads.

She had a point, although the whole idea should've been encouraging Elvis to write more, which could've led to more rock songs. Elvis never lost his love for rock but by the 70s, Parker had created such a bureaucracy in getting good songs of any kind to Elvis, that his publishing liaison, Lamar Fike, came to the studio with fewer and fewer offerings, resulting in Parker trying to grab a third of the publishing on already published songs, a hassle that bothered Elvis so bad (because Parker and his associates did it in the studio as Elvis was recording), Elvis told Parker to stop doing it. Near the end of his life, neither RCA nor Parker could cajole Elvis into the studio because of the fear the sessions would be disrupted by Parker's publishing grabs.

reply

Man, you're unintelligent.

reply