Goldsmith was recommended to do this score by none other than Alfred Newman, who was working on Flower Drum Song at Universal during the same time Freud was being made.
He had noticed JG's work on the Thriller tv series and insisted to the execs at the studio that Goldsmith was the right choice to do the music for Freud.
The score earned Jerry his first Oscar nomination and led to his long-term contract at Fox, and his career took off.
I think his score to Freud is effective and dramatically appropriate.
Of course Herrmann would have done an excellent job, but this was a key assignment in Jerry Goldsmith's early career.
Jerry reused a cue or two from "Freud" in "Alien," but for copyright reasons those cues have never been included in legit "Alien" soundtrack releases.
Actually, the inclusion of music from Freud in Alien was a a desicion made by director Ridley Scott. Goldsmith was against it.
Terry Rawlings maintains that while the use of Howard Hanson's Romantic Symphony was their decision, the Freud cues were retained at the demand of the studio.