Last Supper


Why is the blind man the one to sit in the place of Jesus when the last supper painting is portrayed?

reply

Well, it's open to interpretation.

Possibly to imply the rabble (the church) are being lead by blind hopes, or by blind ideas.

reply

That scene is absolutely BRILLIANT. And I don't know the real meaning of the blind mand as Jesus, but anyway there's a proverb in Spain its says "En el paĆ­s de los ciegos el tuerto es el rey" (In the land of blinds the one-eyed is the king) So... this Jesus is blind and one-eyed, he's less than a citizen (blind). I think the intention is to demystify Jesus and religion, and put the beggars at the same level as Jesus and apostles. It's a desecration. I love it.

reply

So basicall you don't know the real meaning of the blind man as Jesus and yet you love the scene.. Uhm, right..

reply

So basicall you don't know the real meaning of the blind man as Jesus and yet you love the scene.. Uhm, right..


Was that hard for you to understand?



reply

Just out of interest, why do people think during the Angeles scene - where they're saying the Hail Mary in the field - that it cuts to people working i.e chopping wood and all that.

Roma: How was her crumbcake?
Levene: Hmm? Oh... from the store.
Roma: *beep* her.

reply

My first instinct on that "Angels" scene with the prayer on the field and with the shots of instruments, wood, plaster, etc....a contrast between religious piety and asceticism and sexuality. I found the building materials and the rhythmic shots Bunuel presented them with to be very sexually suggestive.

But as with Bunuel, it is all open to interpretation, and I believe that was Don Luis' intent!


Tuco Benedicto Pacifico Juan Maria Ramirez

reply

[deleted]

i thought the scene of the praying in the fields intercut with the shots of the workers brilliantly drew parallels between the laborious physical work and the robotic recitation of the prayers that were empty to everyone besides viridiana.

reply

While some pray, others actually do something. That's about it.

Language! The thing that means stuff.

reply

Maybe. Or about the harmony between work and prayer. Or about how work and prayer complete mutually. Or about how work and prayer both are the facets of the same human existence. Or about Viridiana's spiritual isolation. Or about showing the depth and complexity of beggars' personalities.

That's Bunuel.

Listen to your enemy, for God is talking

reply

Yes absolutely, that was according to me one of the most easy-to-comprehend scenes in the whole movie.

It was like 'don't disturb them, they are working.' Probably that's the reason the shot was cut from one-to-another repeatedly...

reply

the Angeles scene - where they're saying the Hail Mary in the field - that it cuts to people working i.e chopping wood
To me it seemed that the workers were more part of nature and living than the prayer group. The one thing I take from the film is the idea that 'being alone' and serving God is outside of life and unnatural for people.
To say a little often is to tell more than to say a great deal.

reply

About the last supper scene, it's also amusing how the "photo" was taken. I mean with the "camera that father gave her".

reply