MovieChat Forums > The Outsider Discussion > Survived Iwo Jima, but was killed by...

Survived Iwo Jima, but was killed by...


It's a shame that Ira Hayes survived Iwo Jima, but was killed by alcohol. I guess that just goes to show that no matter how strong someone is, they could be a marine, and that stuff can get a hold of them and kill them.

reply

Ira had more problems than alcohol, he had a bad case of post traumatic stress, survivors guilt and living in two different cultures. In 1945 they didnt have support groups for those, AA was in its infancy I believe. He was a good man who was very loyal to his friends and fellow marines, he just couldnt beat his demons. I am disappointed the movie didnt show his trip (mostly hitch hiking) of over 1300 miles to tell Harlon's parents that Harlon was in the Iwo Jima picture so that Harlond would get the honor due him.







reply

Yeah, I read about him doing that. They should've put that in the movie. I know it was a lot of things that destroyed him, but alcohol is literally what got him in the end. He passed out face down in a ditch and died of exposure. Watching The Outsider, it's clear they dramatized is death, but I thought the death scene was very well shot, as I pointed out in my review.

reply

His death in the movie was pretty powerful, but i wonder if Ira would have been pissed by it since he of the three survivors hated all the bs that went on with the bond tours the most. I also didnt like the part about his best friend dying on Iwo Jima when they were told to report to HQ. Ira was already off the island when he was ordered to DC and the friend was fictional.

reply

Yeah, I don't understand why they created the ficitonal friend. I didn't like that part with his friend getting killed either.

reply

creating a fictional friend is one thing, but the fictional friend they created helped raise the flag on iwo Jima, they almost had to have someone play James and Renee, but they never mentioned Mike Harlon or Franklin. I understand the movis was about Ira but still...

reply

I know. They created a fictional friend and didn't even mention his real friends. Mentioning that story about how Ira made sure one of the real flag raisers got credit would've been a nice touch, but they left it out.

reply

I would also like to add another problem he had added to PTSD and survivor's guilt and cultural. Even though we may have not heard his name before nowadays, for a time he had a celebrity status if this story is anything to go by. Then when that had gone, losing revelence can be a killer once fame has touched a person.

reply