MovieChat Forums > La ciociara (1961) Discussion > Is it supposed to be in English?

Is it supposed to be in English?


I bought Two Women at a flea market awhile ago, so I'm assuming the one I bought is a 'bad' copy. Are they really supposed to be speaking English, were they dubbed over with their own voices? The DVD didn't have any other audio, but I assume they must be REALLY speaking Italian.

reply

its supposed to be in Spanish, i saw it on TCM in spanish w/ subs. i know Sophia Loren did her own engish dubbs. I don't know about the other cast members.

If Voldemort's buildng up an Army, Then I want to fight!
www.mugglenet.com

reply

It's Italian, not Spanish. I saw it on Turner Classic Movies and it is definitely Italian. It's an Italian movie!

reply

sorry i sorta get those languages confused. All i knew was i didn't speak the language and as im learning spanish i find there similar. i only really pay attention to the subtitles tho.

If Voldemort's buildng up an Army, Then I want to fight!
www.mugglenet.com

reply

It was made into a TV movie in 1988, also starring Sophia Loren. Perhaps that's the version you have? If you have the 1960 version in English, it is definately dubbed.

reply

I just watched it on Youtube and it was dubbed in English. Does anyone know if Sophia Loren did he own voice-over in English?? I really only watched the movie to see her performance, and as blown away as I was by it in English, if it wasn't her doing the dubbing I'll try to re-watch it in its original Italian to get a true sense of her performance.

reply

I streamed it on Netflix & it was dubbed in English.

reply

I recall it being said that Sophia Loren did her own voice during dubbing.

reply

In the old days the art houses played the original language versions and for wide release to neighborhood cinemas it was often the dubbed version.

reply

The version I am watching is in Italian, but even that sounds dubbed - the sound doesn't match the movement of their lips.

reply

The English language version has been showing on Talking Pictures(UK)and definitely sounds like Sophia Loren did her own dubbing.

reply

I saw it decades ago and managed to get a dvd copy about five years ago in subtitles. The quality is abysmal but with Loren in who cares. Apropos quality, is there a decent print of Rome Open City out yet?

Marlon, Claudia and Dimby the cats 1989-2005, 2007 and 2010.

reply

SPOILER.Loren is fantastic, as is the actress playing her daughter, but I don`t think the film is the classic it should be.The script meanders around in the village during the middle portion of the film and Raf Vallone is sorely missed after what amounts to little more than a cameo.Powerful scenes of the rape and aftermath but the one that sticks in my mind is the woman offering her lactating breast as the Germans have killed her baby.

I`ve not seen Rome Open City yet and still trying to find a nice subtitled version of Four Days Of Naples(1962).It seems that most commercial releases of Two Women are rubbish, although the Talking Pictures print,despite the dubbing,looks like it`s had a proper restoration.

Uomini Contro(1970) is another one worth searching for and out on Italian dvd with subs.They couldn`t do a proper restoration apparently as some idiot has lost the original film negative!

reply

I watched quite a lot of Italian neo-realist films when I was a student and still dabble. I had a look and Criterion have restored Roma città aperta (which is a bit mind numbing to watch) but these days I like Mick Angel films more, especially La Notte which I may have raved about several times.

Marlon, Claudia and Dimby the cats 1989-2005, 2007 and 2010.

reply