The one bad episode in the entire series

I think one of the least enjoyable ones was when they inviting all vaudevillians to come on the show together.
In the 60s vaudeville would have been about 40 years back. But seeing it now it just can't possibly be funny to anyone 30 and under.

however I am 60 and watched DVD when I was a teen and loved it then. Some of my favorites were her dying her hair blond (an early one) and Rob getting arrested on his motorcycle and dying their hands black, and so many more.

But my favorites were any time Danny Thomas or Shelden Leonard were on the show.
There was also one about new neighbors, played by Joby Baker one of the actors of the Frankie Avalon and Elvis Presley, era of movies. He was in the Gidget movies. and seeing him now on that DVD show brings back good memories of being a teen then. Also, the one about the flying saucer was priceless.

I agree the show was just so so the first year. they even called her Laurie. From year 3 on tho, the show was hands down the best.

I saw that episode with Joe Coogan just the other day. In it Laura tells Millie that she doesn't know why she saved all the love letters Joe wrote to her, because she never saved the letters from three other boyfriends (and she names them). So Joe plus three other boys plus Jim Darling plus at least three others mentioned in the other episode equals eight former boyfriends for Laura that we know of--all by the age of 17. (Or maybe 16; we don't know at what age she joined the USO.) And these are just the mentions of boyfriends we can remember right now. Perhaps there are even more, discussed in other episodes.

If Carl Reiner was determined to do these two episodes about Laura and Rob not being legally married, he should have chosen some other plot device as to why their marriage was invalid. The only one I can think of is that the man who performed their ceremony wasn't actually an ordained minister. But because they were married while Rob was still in the service, at Camp Crowder, the wedding would have been performed by a chaplain. And how likely is it that an Army chaplain would be a fake? About as likely as Laura getting married at 17.

It seems like the makers of TV shows back in the '60s didn't care as much about logic and continuity as they do today. If a "Laura's Little Lie" type of episode were shown today as part of a current series, fans would be tearing it apart on the Internet just minutes after its broadcast--and for days afterward!

I haven't seen a lot of the show, but a lot of the episodes I have seen are pretty corny. The whole lie/remarriage thing was pretty silly. The one where Rob cheats on his dentist wasn't funny. But so far the stupidest one I've seen, is when Rob & Laura go away for a romantic weekend, and her big toe gets stuck in the bathtub faucet while Rob is locked out of the bathroom at a hotel. I don't know why, but I just hated that whole episode.

It's not one of my favorite shows, but I do like the time capsule that it is, and the time it represents - there's something charming about that in itself.

"Are you going to your grave with unlived lives in your veins?" ~ The Good Girl

I just watched that episode on Hulu and I agree that scene cracked me up. I don't if it was supposed to be serious but I just thought it was funny how Rob is being all serious. And I love how he has the nerve to tell them "I'm ashamed of each and every one of you!"

[deleted]

I read somewhere that Dick Van Dyke became sick with nerves on the day of filming the first episode and it was too late to cancel the shoot. He wound up with a huge cold sore on his left upper lip (you can see it although they tried to cover it with make-up). I suppose they were trying to make him look human...and went over board. What bothered me was Laura singing the first lines and continuing to sing into the phone when she picked it up. Her "Hello?" is the worst line she ever delivered in the whole series.

I agree with those who say "The Twizzle" is the worst episode. I enjoy "The Square Triangle", especially when Sally almost puts the very special sugar cube in her coffee.

The first episode was kind of odd, but if you take any lasting sitcom and look at its beginnings, you almost invariably see that the show hasn't really become "itself" for a while. I don't think I'd ever seen the first episode till after the series' entire run, and it obviously suffered from "first episode syndrome."

The Beverly Hillbillies had a good pilot episode. The majority of pilots though are testing the water, and people still let out their rage online if the first episode of a new show isn't perfect.

The one and only episode that came to mind seeing the thread was the one with Richie's birthday party. I like The Bad Old Days, but then, I may have a mercenary streak.

And this worst idea was the first seasons when we only see the back of Carl Reiner's head. Why? Some of the greatest episodes are his.

Exactly. The army episodes, guest star showcase episodes, new character on the block who never appears again episodes, etc. just aren't nearly as memorable as the ones that just focused on the main characters. The dynamics between Rob and Laura, Buddy and Sally, Mel and Buddy, etc. and with the whole crew together were just phenomenal and couldn't be replicated when guests took up screen time, for the most part.

If I had to pick just one episode that I wouldn't watch again.... it would probably be the one with the male teenage babysitter who had a crush on Laura. It was pretty unmemorable and seemed pointless since the babysitter never appeared again, which went against the show's spirit of continuity.