The Melodic Debate


In this film Anarkali and Bahar have a singing debate in front of Salim. Is there a particular Indian name for this type of contest, in my english subtitles it was translated as 'A Melodic Debate', which is very beautiful.

my ymdb page: http://www.shompy.com/steppenwolf/l42849_ukuk.html

reply

Hi Matthew...

I believe the song you are refering to is "Teri Mehfil Mein Kismat Aazmakar". One term I found is "jugalbandhi". I am not sure whether the song in question in specifically a "jugalbandhi" but the article on wikipedia gives a description very close to what was witnessed when watching the movie.
Hopefully this is the term you are searching for. I too loved the translation "Melodic Debate". If the world just had more of these debates...who would need war? :)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jugalbandi

reply

thank you niknan, jugalbandhi looks like the word!

my ymdb page: http://www.shompy.com/steppenwolf/l42849_ukuk.html

reply

Jugal bandhi is something entirely different. One musician playing Tabla and another playing sitar, with each other is called jugal bandhi.

The word you are searching is 'Qawwalli Muqabala'.

reply