MovieChat Forums > Home from the Hill (1960) Discussion > Please help....******HUGE SPOILER*******...

Please help....******HUGE SPOILER*************


Who was it that shot and killed Robert Mitchum and why? I do not recognize the man that was tracked down and shot in the woods. Thanks for any help!!

reply

Will send answers to you in private message. Just click the private message link on the top right of this page.

Don't wish to spoil this for others.

reply

Aries, you are correct. I should not have answered on the board. Eventhough it says Huge Spoiler, someone may inadvertantly see the post. Good advice.

reply

Libby's father, Albert, shot and killed Captain. After the baptism, he overheard some of the townsmen gossiping and joking about Captain (Mitchum's character) being the father of Libby's baby. He was furious that they were saying this about his daughter, so he went to the house and killed Captain.

Albert took off in Captain's truck. Theron saw the truck leaving, and followed it out of town until he found it stuck in the mud.

reply

Thank you so very much. Now it all makes sense to me!!!!

I appreciate other posters not wanting to spoil the ending but if someone can't understand ***********HUGE SPOILER******* well......

Thanks again mrssilby

reply

I answered without really thinking but have now deleted my post. You can, too, mrssilby.

reply

The timing of the Captain's death was interesting. He talked his wife into taking a trip with him and reigniting their lifeless marriage. He was working on being a better husband. But it was a sad scene that he refused to acknowledge Rafe as his son before he died. Shows some people are stubborn (and wrong) to the very end. His wife fixed that, putting Rafe's name on his marker. Good for her.

reply

It appeared to me that Captain was already dead before Raph pleaded with him to say, "My son." I could be wrong but this was my impression. Plus I don't have a very large TV screen. lol!

reply

All well and good. But.... WAS Wade the father of Libby's baby??

At the end, Rafe tells the widow that the baby "looks just like his father". Not good enough, IMO. Rafe knows HE did not father the baby, but was it Wade or Theron?? Maybe I'm just too willing to give Wade the benefit of a doubt.

reply

The film leaves no doubt that Theron was the biological father of Libby's baby.

reply

The child's paternity to me is questionable in that

1. Libby did seem a little "forward" for a young girl of that era (going up to the attic w/Theron...at one point I thought he was gonna get it right then and there. THe scene at the lake)

2. When Albert went to the house to speak to Wade about Theron marrying Libby, he admits that they don't know who the father is. If it were Thereon's why wouldn't he have said so?

3. How quick she was to agree to marry her lover's BROTHER and she was the one who initiated sex with aid brother (again, she seemed a bit out there for a young woman of that era)! Also recall, when Rafe first approached Libby to speak on Theron's behalf he said "the next time I come calling it's going to be to speak for myself".......how do we know she wasn't creeping w/Rafe after Theron stopped seeing her?

reply

The scene where Libby tries to give Theron a ride home from work is when she was planning on telling Theron she was pregnant with his child. As she mentioned, it had been six weeks since they had seen each other, just enough time to notice the baby and get tested. She backs out after Theron talks about the hatred between his parents and how he planned on never making the same mistakes. So she doesn't want to trap him, but that puts her in a terrible situation, and Rafe marries her to save her from scandal. She clearly isn't that fast of a woman, just look how long Rafe and Libby wait before getting physical. They were legally married, yet neither of them took advantage. That they both preferred to wait for real love to bloom says a lot.

It is important to the film's themes to understand that Theron found himself making the same mistakes he had grown to hate his father for. He allowed his son to remain legitimate by society's standards, and for the same motives of saving certain loved-ones from scandal. That is why he forgives Wade at the end, and why he passionately runs after Wade's killer. It is only some bitter irony that the child being fathered by Theron meant it resembled a child of Wade's. This triggers the death of Wade, and cements the villain of the story, being the gossip and scandal that controls all the characters in the story.

reply

Thank you, DukeTogo1300. Yes, THERON is the father of the baby. No question about it.

reply

Yes, Theron is the father. But what confused me somewhat in the movie is why Albert doesn't just say so when he comes to see Wade to discuss the possibility of Theron marrying Libby. It seems to me that is what the logical response from Albert would've been. Not only does his actions of not revealing Theron as the father make little sense, but it adds confusion to the viewer.

The other plot point that I didn't get was this mysterious swamp gas. After making such a big deal about it early in the movie, I kept waiting for it to have a big factor whenever somebody went back in the woods, but it never did. Minelli could've removed that all together and you don't lose anything.

reply

I was thinking Albert's tracks would be seen going into the swamp gas and that would end that scene, but.......

reply

[deleted]