MovieChat Forums > La dolce vita (1961) Discussion > Why did I like this but not 8 1/2 or I V...

Why did I like this but not 8 1/2 or I Vitelloni?


Everyone says how Fellini is a genius and a great storyteller, so I watched a few of his movies. I didn't understand them fully by any means but I think La Dolce Vita was miles better than 8 1/2 and I Vitelloni. As far as I'm concerned, there's no question about it. But so many people say 8 1/2 is his masterpiece, and people sure do love all Fellini's movies equally it seems. I just think La Dolce Vita was more entertaining, more atmospheric, more mysterious (to me), and just really interesting to watch. 8 1/2 was so boring! And there was nothing that held my interest with me. Is it because it was much more challenging and deep? Cos like I said, I didn't get both movies but I still loved La Dolce Vita, from what I got from it.

No expectations, no disappointments.

reply

[deleted]

Did you understand everything from I Vitelloni? ... I also felt 8 1/2 was unexplainable when watched the first time but my views changed after the second viewing with commentary.

here's how I rated all three

I Vitelloni - 8/10
8 1/2 - 9/10
La Dolce Vita - 8/10

reply