MovieChat Forums > The Nun's Story (1959) Discussion > Nun gets sick; has to drink beer. Why ?

Nun gets sick; has to drink beer. Why ?


When Sister Luke (A.Hepburn) gets sick - fever ?,

can't remember what illness she had, but the doctor (P.Finch)

says she has to drink beer amongst other things to get better.

What sickness did she have and how would the beer help ?

reply

I don't recall. But in old Europe, beer and wine were drunk instead of water, which was frequently contaminated. Maybe she got sick from the local water...? And isn't beer with its hops and yeast supposedly good for keeping the gut healthy? Just guessing here.

reply

Sister Luke contracted TB, the doctor put her on something called "the gold treatment" and also called it "the gold dust cure", and said its rough on the kidneys; beer is great for running through your system fast, you can almost drink a beer and stand at the urinal at the same time. So, that's what I think, the beer helps cleanse her kidneys out, plus the added benefit from calories; beer is a healthy drink (in moderation), beer like wine is as much a food item as it is a beverage.

Dr. Fortunati being devilish by nature probably thought it would also do her spirit good getting a little beer drunk, I mean, what could be funnier than a drunken nun?

reply

She had Tuberculoais. The beer was to flush her kidneys from the treatmrnt of the time.

reply

Best answer so far.

reply

mvksmall

Beer has been called liquid bread, as it has nourishment and her much needed calories.

"A stitch in time, saves your embarrassment." (RIP Ms. Penny LoBello)

reply

It's because she is Belgian.

Drinking Beer, to a Belgian, is like drinking a Cup of Tea is to the British and both are the solution when faced with a crisis, any crisis.

That's it really.

reply