From cobbled streets to Atlantis


Just wanted add my tributes to this great movie. One of things I love about it is its long running time - just over 2 hours (although there was a cut version many years made to play on tv - they actually cut out the "rolling rock" amongst other scenes). That length of time gave the audience the feeling of really going on a long marvellous journey like the intrepid foursome in the movie. Just think - near the beginning we see a lamplighter light a street lamp in "ye olde Edinburgh" and by the time we get to the end of the film we have fighting dinosaurs, getting sucked into whirlpools and finding Atlantis! Wonderful stuff.
One query - as a child I always found the scene where Boone gets lost as really scarcy - I could easily identify with getting lost forever in some vast catacombs never to be found like the Boone character. Did anybody else have that reaction?

reply

No.

Help stamp out and do away with redundancy

reply

[deleted]

Hell yes. As an adult, you know he's going to live, but even so, the idea that it's completely dark and nobody will ever find you is pretty disturbing.

First they ignore you, then they ridicule you, then they fight you, then you win. Gandhi.

reply

[deleted]

I react same as the OP. Lost underground ... then inevitably ... your crank lamp wears out and you can't recharge it because the salt has corroded the coils. Utter darkness, utter silence but for your own breathing ...

reply

[deleted]

I give you a week. No -- three days.



You never know what you have until you've lost it.

reply

[deleted]

A-ha! So...you've been down there?

reply

[deleted]

Sorry, I was making a light comment not intended as an insult or judgment (positive or negative) on you personally...or anyone else, for that matter. I think that was pretty obvious. Given the subject, it's rather silly to get so offended.

However, there's more to the situation you posited than simply living in isolation. Eating mushrooms and drinking "virgin" water isn't enough to sustain human life in the long run, the psychological issue of monotony aside. People also require some degree of medical care, there are various hygiene issues, and so on. If, for example, you fell and broke a leg, or suffered some other kind of serious injury or illness, continuing to live -- or to try to live -- in isolation, with virtually no resources and absolutely no help, might not be the most pleasant existence. There are also the inevitable mental and emotional issues that will crop up -- not merely loneliness, but lack of true or sustainable mental stimulation and involvement with more than one's tiny immediate world.

Point is, no matter how well you may think you can live in the kind of very real, total, absolute isolation you describe, the fact is no one can know what such an existence is really like without living it. Perhaps you've lived in some form of isolation, but it's highly unlikely it was anything like the hypothetical existence you describe here, and in any case you're not living that way now if you're on the internet, so you could (and did) escape from such an existence.

Anyway, you may believe you could live in such a way, and maybe you could. Since I indeed don't know you, I couldn't say definitively...though I can fairly say I think the odds are heavily against leading the blissful existence you describe. On the other hand, you could as easily be kidding yourself about how readily you could spend the rest of your life that way. Self-delusion is a common human trait to which we all succumb to some degree, at one time or another, though usually over minor things.

However, this entire discussion is, if nothing else, moot -- since the center of the Earth isn't exactly the way it's depicted in this movie. So this whole exchange is pretty pointless.

reply

[deleted]

I take it back, I.I. You certainly have no need for any mental stimulation. Have a good life.

reply

[deleted]

Yes, that's what I call it, but then, I understand that not all human thought can be encapsuled in six words of one syllable or less. Anyway, since you prefer isolation, here's your opportunity.

reply

[deleted]

for what it's worth I've oome across ironclad before. He/she is in jr high.

suzycreamcheese RIP Heath Ledger 1979-2008

reply

I've run across him/her a couple of times too. Junior High would explain a lot, including the inadequacies of our present educational system. Thanks for the heads-up!

reply