I don't think Esther staying with Fitzgerald would have been a "happy ending" at all because it ignores her right to have happiness of her own. Just because he revealed that his sadism was the result of his own insecurity doesn't make him sympathetic or lovable.
My suggestion for an alternate ending wouldn't have ignored her right to happiness; it would have provided it, if the piano changed him but the piano did *not*.
If it was scripted where Fitzgerald's admissions brought his realization of his sadism to the surface where he recognized it and was repulsed by it, he could have been the man that Esther wanted the whole time - the man she though she was getting when he married her. I though when he was vulnerable that's where the story was headed.
But it wasn't scripted that way. It showed Fitzgerald, even after the piano stopped, being a total tool. If anything, the piano changed him permanently into the "spoiled child".
reply
share