MovieChat Forums > The Lineup (1958) Discussion > What did you rate ''The Lineup'' (1958)?

What did you rate ''The Lineup'' (1958)?


In San Francisco, two police inspectors (Marshall Reed and Emile Meyer) are on the case when a rogue taxi driver, with the help of a rogue porter, manages to steal the suitcase of an antiques collector before running down a cop, whose dying gesture is to shoot the cabbie dead. The inspectors discover that an antique statue in the suitcase contains heroin. Meanwhile, a psychopathic gangster (Eli Wallach), his malignant mentor (Robert Keith) and their dipsomaniac driver (Richard Jaeckel) have the job of picking up the other heroin shipments, hidden in the luggage of unsuspecting travelers. All goes well until they attempt to retrieve the heroin stuffed in a Japanese doll. A little girl and her lovely young mother (Cheryl Callaway and Mary LaRoche) have the doll, but when the crooks take possession of it, they find that the heroin has mysteriously vanished.

Don Siegel, working from a script by Stirling Silliphant, does a bang-up job directing this explosive crime thriller, which is filled with violent action, surprise plot twists, a spectacular murder in an indoor ice rink and a great climactic car chase. The characters of the police inspectors are carried over from the same-titled TV series, but unlike the show, the movie is mainly concerned with the criminals. Wallach is the star, brilliantly portraying a dangerous man who can be calm, even genial, but reveals his true nature when others try to push him around. The cadaverous Keith is properly ghoulish, especially while taking note of the day's victims' dying words. Callaway proves to be a very adept child actress, while her lovely screen mother, LaRoche (who also had trouble with her daughter's doll in a "Twilight Zone" episode), ably performs the difficult task of remaining in a perpetual state of panic.

The plot requires a fairly high suspension of disbelief, especially considering the general air of realism, but few will gripe about plausibility in this exciting action drama.

imdb.com/title/tt0051866/ratings

I rated this film 8/10 for the database. What did you rate it? What did you think of it?


...Justin

reply

[deleted]

How did you hear about this movie? I learned about it when James Ellroy (who delivers the commentary on the DVD) listed it as one of his favorite movies.


...Justin

reply

[deleted]

I watched that whole set. Have you watched any of the others yet?


...Justin

reply

[deleted]

9/10

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

9.

One of my favorites. The TV series was excellent as well.

reply

I gave it a 9.. Loved it. Great locations and Eli W. And his mentor were excellent.

reply

I rated it 9/10. You can tell that Don Siegel did this study of two hit men with unusual personality traits as a forerunner to "The Killers" in 1964 where they were more central to the plot.

The scene between psychotic "Dancer" played by Eli Wallach and "The Man" by Vaughn Taylor is one I watched more than once.

reply

I rated it a 6/10.

reply