MovieChat Forums > The 7th Voyage of Sinbad (1958) Discussion > A little logic pokes all kinds of holes ...

A little logic pokes all kinds of holes in this film. (Spoilers)


Where was Sokurah's ship? We see him running toward the beach, but there's no other ship in sight. Was he marooned? Was he going to have the genie teleport him back to civilization?

If Sokurah has a king's ransom in jewels, why not find another crew who hasn't heard the cyclops? What a shame that Bagdad is the only place in the world where one can find sailors.

The crossbow is a rather impractical method of dealing with the cyclops. The concept is valid, but the bow is apparently so massive that it has to be left on the beach. Was that really their strategy? Hope to outrun the cyclops until they make it to the beach, then open fire?

Lastly, we see that the dragon still regards Sokurah as its master even when it's not restrained. So why didn't he just march the dragon up to where the treasure was and have it fight the cyclops? He's kind of a heartless fellow, so I doubt he regards it as a beloved pet. Even if it died in combat, he'd still be able to get the lamp while the cyclops was distracted.

--

Yeah, I know. It's a movie. And a very fun one. But it's still kind of amusing how many gaps in logic there are. You just kinda have to accept that things work out the way they work out.

reply

You're over thinking it. It's a fantasy. You might as well question how Santa's reindeer get off the ground, or how the tooth fairy never woke you as a child and so forth.

Sokurah may have been there for centuries. His ship long destroyed. And you can't pay a new crew in jewels. Only royalty ore wealthy merchants can convert jewels to gold, which is what you need to pay a crew.

The crossbow was for the dragon.

The rest of your post is equally ill informed.

reply

Where was Sokurah's ship? We see him running toward the beach, but there's no other ship in sight. Was he marooned? Was he going to have the genie teleport him back to civilization?


Why would he need a ship? He lives on the island. He's got a whole lair with a dragon guarding it.

If Sokurah has a king's ransom in jewels, why not find another crew who hasn't heard the cyclops? What a shame that Bagdad is the only place in the world where one can find sailors.


Sokurah didn't have the money on him. He needed a crew that would want to get paid after the voyage.

Was that really their strategy? Hope to outrun the cyclops until they make it to the beach, then open fire?


No. The strategy was to not get caught at all. The crossbow was a failsafe.

So why didn't he just march the dragon up to where the treasure was and have it fight the cyclops?


There's more than one cyclops on the island. There's no guarantee it would be a one-on-one fight.

All the "gaps in logic" are easily explainable.

You are sin.

reply

It has a cyclops and a genie in it so...logic doesn't really apply.
It also has a Cyclops vs a Dragon meaning all illogicality is instantly forgiven.


Hey, look at that! She's not crazy, she's being chased by a cheetah!

reply

And when the princess is suddenly magically turned into four inches long, nobody seems to suspect the magician for it...

reply