MovieChat Forums > The Incredible Shrinking Man (1957) Discussion > What would you have liked to happen to s...

What would you have liked to happen to scott carey?


I think the story is somewhat muddled and gets too bogged down with hollywood...the cat chasing him, the spider battle, the existential crap at the end.

If you were to tell the story of man shrinking in size, how would you do it differently. How would you tell the story more realistically? I dont think the movie captures what it would really be like for a manwho was shrinking a little at a time. How would he respond to his friends and his family? How would his wife respond to the day to day horrors? What if scott had kids of various ages? How would they respond to a shrinking dad?

Any ideas on this topic would be very interesting. Who knows, we may be getting that remake after all and your comments might get to the director so share what youd like to see!

reply

[deleted]

BOOK.I DIDNT KNOW THEY MADE A BOOK OUT OF IT.SEE YA LETS GO METS

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I would rather go into your socks

reply

Hmmmmmmmmm sounds interesting. Actually I would have liked to seen a bit more in the movie of him getting real small, I mean one minute he is like 3FT next 3 Inches ! Would have been quite funny seeing a very attractive Dianna Darrin seeing how he 'measured' up. I would quite like a young Dianna Darrin taking my inside leg measurement even with a micrometer lol.

reply

[deleted]

>>What if scott had kids of various ages?

he has a 5 yr old daughter in the book version

reply

I would have liked scott to have had 3 older children...

amanda carey ..17 years old

jake carey 15 years old

and kelli- ann carey... 13 or 14 years old

how would these kids have responded to a shrinking dad?

Beth was too young to understand and she treated her dad like an unruly pet. She had to be removed from her fathers presence as she was too much of a threat like the cat or the spider.

reply

I would think Amanda and Kelly would have wanted to mommy their dad a lot, like feeding him, taking care of him, having him in their bedroom and sleep in their dollhouses, to the point they would bring him to school to show off to their girlfriends, but a con if they had boyfriends. For Jake, I have no clue

I agree about your thought dreuxcut, it would be far better if Scott had 3 older children. I would think though that if he was smaller than what he appear to look, his teenage daughters would be the ones to take care of Scott as he has to viewed as an embarassment to not father his own daughters, anymore.

OBVIOUSLY

reply

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

[deleted]

I wish Scott Carey would have spent more time at around 6-12 inches in height. Seeing the house so big around him, having him deal with his wife not seeing him as her husband, etc. I also would have like to see him fall in oatmeal, seeing even food was a hazard for him. Maybe having a child in the movie would have added some depth to how changed his life was becoming.

reply

I agree that it would have been nice for Scott to have spent more time than he does in that height bracket (six to twelve inches). When he is reduced to mere inches, the film takes on a Horror feeling, more than before, as it thus far has veered between Drama and Science Fiction.

If Scott could have remained visible longer than he has, then The Incredible Shrinking Man could concentrate upon his resolve to perservere and make amends instead of giving up. As it is, he does try to survive and to make peace, true. But he doesn't receive the opportunity to come to terms with his past.

As it remains, Louise and Scott's brother are left to believe that the cat has done him in. I would have given Scott a friend to share his time, even a mad scientist, who could reverse the effect for a more upbeat climax than stands.


“Keep your fears to yourself, but share your courage with others.” — Robert Louis Stevenson

reply

Believe it or not, there are websites with shrinking stories. One is Giatessworld.net (I think it;s a .NET address(. The other one is Giatesscity.com

reply

I though the spider goo that dripped on him should've been the cure. The plumber could find him passed out the next day.

reply