THIS FILM IS HORRIBLE!!!


To a historian like myself, this movie is one big pile of garbage. It's a slap in the face to historians and an insult. If you want to make a movie about Wyatt Earp and the gunfight at OK Corral for God's sake please have a bit of historical accuracy. The casting is HORRIBLE, except for Kurt Douglas who delivers a fine performance and is the only one with a mustache and the sexy Rhonda Fleming everybody else is pathetic. For starters the wild west composed of men, real men, who were dirty, gruff and tough and that wore facial hair. Burt Lancaster is a wimp and Douglass would of made a better Earp. The two of them should of switched roles. I think Lancaster doesn't wear a mustache because back then the studios had a difficult time selling an actor to the audience who was covered up with some facial hair. The same thing happened to Gregory Peck in the 1950 film The Gunfighter where he wore a mustache, playing Johnny Ringo. The film bombed because audiences didn't like seeing him with the mustache. Reality check. Their actors, they have to get into their role. That's there job. Lancaster is pathetic for not getting into his role, such as Douglas did. The other cast is just as atrocious. The Clanton gang aren't the least bit threating and the producers of this awful film should of taken note of My Darling Clementine to see what a Clanton looks like. Walter Brennan as Ike Clanton in that film was truly great and mean. It's one of his many underrated roles of such a amazing actor. The Earp brothers played by DeForest Kelly and others, is also horrible. I didn't care much for Bill Paxton in the role of Tombstone as Morgan, but he sure does look more tougher and accurate in the role then old Bones does. John Ireland as Johnny Ringo is also a joke. Ringo is supposed to be a psycho. Ireland is too much of a wimp. Two notable actors who played Ringo with perfection is of course Michael Biehn in Tombstone who was absolutely amazing and Peck.

I'm not going to even mention the problems with the inaccurate history. I'll be writing a book. All I have to say is it's just awful. I can't even think of enough descriptive words, because I'm beside myself at how bad this film is. It sucks and it's a piece of trash. The only positives in this film is Douglas, Fleming, and Dimitri Tiomkin's musical score. Tiomkin I think is the greatest movie composer ever and two years later after this crap he would score the movie Rio Bravo which is my favorite western of all time and has a stellar Tiomikin score. Skip this crappy movie and if you want historical accuracy of Wyatt Earp and the gunfight at OK Corral watch Tombstone. * out of ****

reply

So you think that the wimp should have played the outlaw Doc Holliday? Doesn't make much sense to me.

reply

[deleted]

I though Gregory Peck's character in "The Gunfighter" was Jimmy Ringo
not Johnny. And I don't recall Rhonda Fleming sporting a moustache in "OK Corral" either. HUH?

Windage and elevation my dear friend.......windage and elevation!

reply

Errol1909, if you're planning on writing a book, you really should learn the difference between "there, their, and they're!" Oh, and by the way, this was an excellent movie! Notice I said movie, not documentary. Movies don't have to be historically accurate, they're entertainment. Historical accuracy is for documentaries.

reply

I won't read your overlong post, I will however put you on IGNORE for your use of uppercase and the even more pathetic multiple exclamation points.

Perhaps the OP just wants to reach out for some sense of community.

reply

Hello Errol.

You may well have written your book by now but, if not, in addition to the points on grammar mentioned by others, I hope that you realise in time that it's "would/should HAVE", not "of". Goodness knows how this stupid and illiterate error has crept into our language over the last forty or so years.

reply

The widespread solecism "would of" came about through common use of the contraction "would`ve" ("would have") in speech. Semi-literates (e.g., the OP) hear the "`ve" as "of" and transcribe it accordingly.

🇺🇸 Liberty and Union, Now and Forever, One and Inseparable. 🇺🇸

reply

I was about to explain how this is not a documentary film, but then I saw this:

"except for Kurt Douglas..."

Funny enough most others didn't catch that there is no actor named "Kurt Douglas" either.

reply

oh man, there is always that one guy complaining about historical accuracy

it must truly suck to be one of you guys





so many movies, so little time

reply