MovieChat Forums > All Mine to Give Discussion > If it was mine to give id give it away!!

If it was mine to give id give it away!!


This movie was a major suck fest. The acting was atrocious! What a sucky movie I hated it!

reply

>> This movie was a major suck fest. The acting was atrocious! What a sucky movie I hated it!
<<

Whatever. I just got through watching it. You're so full of crap, whoever you are.

reply

I loved it (cried my eyes out) and I wish it was available on DVD!

reply

By the postings on this messages board, this film looks to be about as polarizing as any I can remember. Some people love it, have loved it all their lives, and cry their eyes out every time they watch it. Others detest it, consider it a total waste of perfectly good celluloid. As for myself, I come down somewhere in the middle. I cried a time or two along the way, but I also kept thinking, "Gee, this could have been so much better." Long before the end, my "you-can-cry-now" buttons were tired of being pushed, and I was watching it from the outside, just waiting for it to answer all the plot questions and come to an end. I think I'll remember it for a long time, even if the rather generic-sounding title slips out of my ever-less-resilient memory. Interesting anyway. I'm glad I saw it. I'll probably see it again. Leonard Maltin gives it 2.5 stars, which sounds about right to me.

I started this reply to suggest that maybe this film is a sort of Myers-Briggs test for the Thinking/Feeling dichotomy. Feelers love it, while Thinkers hate it. I'm INFP myself, so the Feeler in me responded to it, but I'm borderline T, so Thinker side kept thinking through the tears, "Those Hollywood hacks!"

(Just to answer before it's asked, you can read about the Myers-Briggs Type Indicator at http://www.myersbriggs.org/.)

Thanks,
Alan

reply

The OP recently died of a mysterious respiratory accident. You don't have her to kick around no more.

If you put me on ignore, then how can I notify you when I win the lottery?

reply